The Decrease in Traumatic Brain Injury Epidemics Deriving from Road Traffic Collision Following Strengthened Legislative Measures in France

Abstract

BackgroundSince 2002, France has been strengthening legislation on road traffic. This study is intended to evaluate the changes in Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) incidence and mortality resulting from Road Traffic Collision (RTC) in the two 6-year periods before and after 2002.MethodsWe used a Registry of all RTC casualties in the Rhône Department of France. Each casualty was coded according to the Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS). The study describes changes in demographic variables, TBI (AIS ≥ 2) incidence and mortality, other body lesions (AIS ≥ 3) associated with TBI, road user types, seatbelt and helmet wearing.FindingsRTC casualty occurrences decreased by 21% (from 64,312 to 50,746) during the period after 2002. TBI occurrence accounted for 8.6% and 6.7% of all RTC in both periods. This corresponds to a reduction of TBI casualty incidence (-42%), which was much more pronounced than RTC casualty incidence (-25%) (p < 0.0001). Severe and critical TBI (AIS-4 and -5) incidences were reduced by half as much (-21%), compared to TBI incidence. TBI mortality rate (among population) and lethality (among TBI related to RTC casualties) decreased 56% and 23%, respectively. This reduction particularly affected car occupants and victims who deceased. TBI incidence decreased 43% in all 10-year age classes until 60 on average, this decrease declining with age in the period after 2002. After adjustment for age, sex, road user types, and severity of lesions at the head and other body regions, logistic regression analysis displayed a protective effect of the period following 2002, on the risk of death after RTC-related TBI.InterpretationThe greater reductions in the incidence, severity and mortality of TBI when compared with the reduction of casualty incidence have mainly affected car users. These results should be attributable to the improvements in standards of care, primary safety of the car fleet and general road architecture safety. However, the increased reduction in the TBI epidemics in France, when compared to those observed in other developed countries for the same periods, suggests that the effects should be strongly attributable to changes in road user behaviour induced by law enforcement. The at-risk groups for TBI after RTC are now two-wheel users (motorized or not) and individuals over 60 years of age.

Epidemiological characteristics for patients with traumatic brain injury and the nomogram model for poor prognosis: an 18-year hospital-based study

“…Considering the rapid urbanization, improved traffic regulation, and aging population in the past decades in China, it was not surprising that our results simultaneously reflected both the characteristics of middle- and low-income countries and high-income countries. First, preventive measures improved traffic safety and reduced the incidence of traffic accidents, which especially decreased the risk for younger individuals ( 5 , 22 ). Second, the implementation of the amended Criminal Law, which imposed harsher punishments on driving under the influence (DUI), demonstrated unequivocal success, and the incidence of traffic accident-related TBI has decreased by over 50% since 2011 ( 9 ).…”

The relationship between road traffic collision dynamics and traumatic brain injury pathology

“…Nevertheless, our estimated rate of mild–probable and moderate–severe TBI in national police-reported collisions of 6% is similar to a previous study French study that estimated a rate of 6.7% for TBI following RTCs. 72 …”

Traumatic brain injuries in Aotearoa New Zealand adolescents: Health inequity pathways from upstream factors to downstream causes

“…2,9,12 Although the efficacy of these changes are yet to be evaluated in Aotearoa, other countries have shown a reduction in TBI incidence due to similar legislative changes. 45,46 The Warrant of Fitness to regularly test the safety of vehicles is another NZTA policy that has proven to be successful at reducing the road vehicle crashes which are a major cause of TBI. 43 The Sale and Supply of Alcohol Act 2012 is another example of protective legislation which introduced restrictions on the licensing, promotion and supply of alcohol to young people.…”