The Demand for Social Insurance: Does Culture Matter?

Abstract

Can different social groups develop different demands for social insurance of risks to health and work? We study this issue across language groups in Switzerland. Language defines social groups and Swiss language groups are separated by a clear geographic border. Actual levels of social insurance are identical on either side of the within state segments of the language border. We can therefore study the role of culture in shaping the demand for social insurance. Specifically, we contrast at the language border actual voting decisions on country-wide changes to social insurance programs. Key results indicate substantially higher support for expansions of social insurance among residents of Latin-speaking (i.e. French, Italian, or Romansh) border municipalities compared to their German-speaking neighbors in adjacent municipalities. We consider three possible explanations for this finding: informal insurance, ideology, and the media. We find that informal insurance does not vary enough to explain stark differences in social insurance. However, differences in ideology and segmented media markets are potentially important explanatory factors.JEL classification: J21, J64, Z10

How Time Preferences Differ: Evidence from 45 Countries

“…As Fehr and Hoff (2011) noted, such views become obsolete with the growing literature showing that preferences can be endogenous and can be shaped by societal and cultural influence (Bowles, 1998;Henrich, 2000;Stern, Dethier, & Rogers, 2005;Eugster, Lalive, Steinhauer, & Zweimüller, 2011;Hoff, Kshetramade, & Fehr, 2011).…”

Effects of Siblings and Birth Order on Income Redistribution Preferences: Evidence Based on Japanese General Social Survey

“…The current study used survey data, whereas Fehr et al (2008) used data gathered from experiments. Apart from the difference in methodology, the cultural and social background were also different between studies, which caused a difference in value and, therefore, economic preference (e.g., Chang 2010; Eugster et al, 2011;Fehr and Hoff 2011;Luttmer. 2011).…”

Tastes, Castes, and Culture: The Influence of Society on Preferences

“…Whether this preference difference holds more generally between the US and Europe is, however, not known. Eugster et al (2011), in this symposium, study the impact of differences across language groups in the demand for social insurance across the cultural boundary defined by German and "Latin" (i.e. French, Italian, and Romansh) language groups in Switzerland.…”