The design and analysis of longitudinal studies of development and psychopathology in context: Statistical models and methodological recommendations

Abstract

The utility and flexibility of recent advances in statistical methods for the quantitative analysis of developmental data—in particular, the methods of individual growth modeling and survival analysis—are unquestioned by methodologists, but have yet to have a major impact on empirical research within the field of developmental psychopathology and elsewhere. In this paper, we show how these new methods provide developmental psychpathologists with powerful ways of answering their research questions about systematic changes over time in individual behavior and about the occurrence and timing of life events. In the first section, we present a descriptive overview of each method by illustrating the types of research questions that each method can address, introducing the statistical models, and commenting on methods of model fitting, estimation, and interpretation. In the following three sections, we offer six concrete recommendations for developmental psychopathologists hoping to use these methods. First, we recommend that when designing studies, investigators should increase the number of waves of data they collect and consider the use of accelerated longitudinal designs. Second, we recommend that when selecting measurement strategies, investigators should strive to collect equatable data prospectively on all time-varying measures and should never standardize their measures before analysis. Third, we recommend that when specifying statistical models, researchers should consider a variety of alternative specifications for the time predictor and should test for interactions among predictors, particularly interactions between substantive predictors and time. Our goal throughout is to show that these methods are essential tools for answering questions about life-span developmental processes in both normal and atypical populations and that their proper use will help developmental psychopathologists and others illuminate how important contextual variables contribute to various pathways of development.

A Longitudinal Assessment of the Links Between Physical Activity and Self-Esteem in Early Adolescent Non-Hispanic Females

“…Statistical analyses-We used an individual growth model [25][26][27][28] to examine (a) the lagged effect of physical activity on self-esteem and (b) the lagged effect of self-esteem on physical activity. We chose this analytical method because it makes full use of the data from all three time points, it models the within person correlation across time, and it assesses the two lagged activity effects (9-11 and 11-13) simultaneously, thereby decreasing the likelihood of a type I error, increasing the number of data points from 166 (when modeling self-esteem at age 11) or 161 (when modeling self-esteem at age 13) to 327, and increasing the statistical power.…”

Internalized weight stigma moderates eating behavior outcomes in women with high BMI participating in a healthy living program

“…pointÓ approach that was developed for fixed effects regression models (Rogosa, 1980; Aiken & 311 West, 1991) and further extended to multi-level, or growth-curve models with subject-specific 312 random effects (Bryk & Raudenbush, 1987;Willet, Singer, & Martin, 1998). Trajectories of 313 change depicting individuals who scored 1 standard deviation (SD) above the mean on 314 internalized weight stigma and those who scored 1 SD below the mean were used as anchors on 315 the graphs.…”

Persistent maternal depressive symptoms trajectories influence children's IQ: The EDEN mother-child cohort

“…To identify trajectories of maternal depressive symptoms we needed to meaningfully combine the scores of both instruments, which have different possible symptom severity score ranges. Thus, the scores for each instrument were standardized by the sample mean and standard deviation for each time point to t-scores (M = 50, SD =10) , which allowed us to study them jointly as continuous measures [16,17] .…”