The design and evaluation of a tool to support software designers at the whiteboard

Abstract

Despite the availability of advanced software design tools, software developers are known to frequently turn to the whiteboard when faced with a specific design problem. Free from any restrictions, they engage in an informal form of software design that relies heavily on sketching. However, whereas whiteboards afford flexibility and fluidity, they at the same time limit a designer in only being able to draw and erase content. This paper presents Calico, a novel software design tool that leverages electronic whiteboards to enhance the design experience with explicit support for the creative, exploratory aspects of design. Specifically, Calico offers a grid to partition the drawing space, scraps to organize and manipulate the content, and a reusable palette together with gesture-based input to address several natural behaviors exhibited by software designers, including frequent shifts in focus, use of low-detail models, use of a variety of notations, and a tendency to refine representations. To evaluate Calico, we performed a laboratory experiment involving the design of an educational traffic simulator. Through a three-pronged analysis examining the use of Calico's features, design behaviors exhibited by the participants, and the nature of the design conversations, we show how Calico benefits the design process as it takes place at the whiteboard.

Improving task breakdown comprehensiveness in agile projects with an Interaction Room

“…Comparable contemporary approaches can e.g. be found in the visual architecture modeling techniques of Mangano and van der Hoek [13].…”

Towards Agent Dialogue as a Tool for Capturing Software Design Discussions

“…However, it is not entirely clear whether and how the use of the whiteboard could be fit into our current model. Some initial work on whiteboard usage exists [8], but this takes a more conversation-analytic approach focussed on the mechanics of interaction. As a result Mangano et al have developed a novel tool for intelligent whiteboards to support some of the specific interaction styles observed.…”

Enhancing the quality of software design through multi-touch interfaces

“…Therefore, it is important to support co-located rather than remote collaborative design [20]. Similarly, some research attempts have been made to facilitate collaborative software design in a co-located setting, such as Calico [21]. However, Calico has limitations that prevent parallel work.…”