Two numerical crack propagation models, namely the cohesive model and the CTOA model, are compared regarding their ability to predict the crack propagation behaviour of fracture specimens made of thin walled Aluminium sheets, which can be simulated using plane stress assumption. The experimental database is presented and it is shown, how the various quantities are measured by different techniques (optically and with various clip gauges). It is explained how the respective parameters for the numerical models are determined by use of a selected set of fracture specimens. Other types of specimens are then used to validate the simulations with these parameters. In order to investigate the behaviour of the models under different constraint conditions and the transferability of their parameters, C(T) specimens are used for parameter evaluation and M(T) specimens for validation. It is shown that for all types of specimens, a single set of parameters can be used for both models.