The development of a fully-integrated immune response model (FIRM) simulator of the immune response through integration of multiple subset models

Abstract

BackgroundThe complexity and multiscale nature of the mammalian immune response provides an excellent test bed for the potential of mathematical modeling and simulation to facilitate mechanistic understanding. Historically, mathematical models of the immune response focused on subsets of the immune system and/or specific aspects of the response. Mathematical models have been developed for the humoral side of the immune response, or for the cellular side, or for cytokine kinetics, but rarely have they been proposed to encompass the overall system complexity. We propose here a framework for integration of subset models, based on a system biology approach.ResultsA dynamic simulator, the Fully-integrated Immune Response Model (FIRM), was built in a stepwise fashion by integrating published subset models and adding novel features. The approach used to build the model includes the formulation of the network of interacting species and the subsequent introduction of rate laws to describe each biological process. The resulting model represents a multi-organ structure, comprised of the target organ where the immune response takes place, circulating blood, lymphoid T, and lymphoid B tissue. The cell types accounted for include macrophages, a few T-cell lineages (cytotoxic, regulatory, helper 1, and helper 2), and B-cell activation to plasma cells. Four different cytokines were accounted for: IFN-γ, IL-4, IL-10 and IL-12. In addition, generic inflammatory signals are used to represent the kinetics of IL-1, IL-2, and TGF-β. Cell recruitment, differentiation, replication, apoptosis and migration are described as appropriate for the different cell types. The model is a hybrid structure containing information from several mammalian species. The structure of the network was built to be physiologically and biochemically consistent. Rate laws for all the cellular fate processes, growth factor production rates and half-lives, together with antibody production rates and half-lives, are provided. The results demonstrate how this framework can be used to integrate mathematical models of the immune response from several published sources and describe qualitative predictions of global immune system response arising from the integrated, hybrid model. In addition, we show how the model can be expanded to include novel biological findings. Case studies were carried out to simulate TB infection, tumor rejection, response to a blood borne pathogen and the consequences of accounting for regulatory T-cells.ConclusionsThe final result of this work is a postulated and increasingly comprehensive representation of the mammalian immune system, based on physiological knowledge and susceptible to further experimental testing and validation. We believe that the integrated nature of FIRM has the potential to simulate a range of responses under a variety of conditions, from modeling of immune responses after tuberculosis (TB) infection to tumor formation in tissues. FIRM also has the flexibility to be expanded to include both complex and novel immunologi...

Modeling putative therapeutic implications of exosome exchange between tumor and immune cells

“…Other types of modeling methods have also been applied. For example, tumor growth has also been fitted to experimental data by artificial neural networks (42); a detailed network of cancer immune system has been modeled by multiple subset models (43).…”

Importance of Feedback and Feedforward Loops to Adaptive Immune Response Modeling

“…It will also help designing the de‐immunization strategy to reduce the overall immunogenicity. Recently, several mathematical models of the immune system have been developed to predict immunogenicity of drug therapeutics 93, 95, 96, 97. The investigation of feedback‐FFLs in the immune system is lacking, with some notable exceptions 98, 99, 100.…”

Recipient Pretransplant Inosine Monophosphate Dehydrogenase Activity in Nonmyeloablative Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation

“…The FIRM model was created with a systems biology approach using mathematical models developed by integrating models of the humoral side of the immune response, the cellular side of immune response, and for cytokine kinetics. (46) This model accurately simulated the immune response to a tuberculosis infection, a blood borne pathogen, immune-mediated tumor elimination, and tumor removal with Tregs. Future work should include the application of immune models to allogeneic HCT.…”