The development of a set of key points to aid clinicians and researchers in designing and conducting n-of-1 trials

Abstract

Introduction: n-of-1 trials are undertaken to optimise the evaluation of health technologies in individual patients. They involve a single patient receiving treatments, both interventional and control, consecutively over set periods of time, the order of which is decided at random. Although n-of-1 trials are undertaken in medical research it could be argued they have the utility to be undertaken more frequently. We undertook the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) commissioned DIAMOND (Development of generalisable methodology for n-of-1 trials delivery for very low volume treatments) project to develop key points to assist clinicians and researchers in designing and conducting n-of-1 trials. Methods The key points were developed by undertaking a stakeholder workshop, followed by a discussion within the study team and then a stakeholder dissemination and feedback event. The stakeholder workshop sought to gain the perspectives of a variety of stakeholders (including clinicians, researchers and patient representatives) on the design and use of n-of-1 trials. A discussion between the study team was held to reflect on the workshop and draft the key points. Lastly, the stakeholders from the workshop were invited to a dissemination and feedback session where the proposed key points were presented and their feedback gained. Results A set of 22 key points were developed based on the insights from the workshop and subsequent discussions. They provide guidance on when an n-of-1 trial might be a viable or appropriate study design and discuss key decisions involved in the design of n-of-1 trials, including determining an appropriate number of treatment periods and cycles, the choice of comparator, recommended approaches to randomisation and blinding, the use of washout periods and approaches to analysis. Conclusions The key points developed in the project will support clinical researchers to understand key considerations when designing n-of-1 trials. It is hoped they will support the wider implementation of the study design.