The Development of Comprehension of Main Ideas in Narratives: Evidence From the Selection of Titles.

Abstract

The authors investigated readers' ability to identify main ideas in narrative texts and the development of this ability. In particular, the authors explored students' sensitivity to the goal structure of narratives. Third-, 6th-, 9th-, and 11th-grade students read narratives in which goal statements were systematically varied on 2 structural dimensions: position in the text's hierarchical structure and number of connections to other statements. As a measure of main idea comprehension, students selected titles for the narratives from among the goals or associated outcomes. Hierarchical position, but not number of connections, influenced title choices. Even the youngest students were able to identify the main ideas, but they did so less consistently than did older students. These findings have implications for theories of text comprehension development and for educational practice.

Assessment of Students’ Higher-level Text Comprehension Skills in Basic School

“…In addition, the reader has to analyse the text before evaluating it (Kaplan, 2013). Thus, our results are in accordance with earlier studies which have shown that students at this age are better in tasks which require much lower-level cognitive skills (Kaplan, 2013;Uibu, & Mannamaa, 2014;Van den Broek et al, 2003;Veeravagu et al, 2010).…”

“…Problems occur when texts have to be analyzed, evaluated and integrated with student's prior knowledge (Pandis, 2008;Sinka, 2008). By the age of 15 students should have the cognitive skills to analyse, evaluate and integrate texts (Van den Broek, Lunch, Naslund, Levers-Landis & Verduin, 2003). That is why it is important to study the students' text comprehension at the age of 10-12.…”

Be Kind to Three-Legged Dogs: Children's Literal Interpretations of TV's Moral Lessons

“…He argued that part of young children's difficulty in extracting the gist of televised stories is that they tend to forget the main character's superordinate goal, even though this goal typically serves as the narrative glue that binds the events of the story together (Van den Broek, 1997;van den Broek, Lynch, Naslund, Ievers-Landis, & Verduin, 2003). Not surprisingly then, Mares (2006) found that when 6-to 8-year-old children were asked to generate the moral lessons of the Disney animated film, The Sword in the Stone, very few did so correctly.…”

When all children comprehend: increasing the external validity of narrative comprehension development research

“…Goal structure understanding also increases understanding of main ideas (van den Broek et al, 2003). Few studies have investigated the impact of variations in goal structures.…”