The Development of Generalized Trust among Young People in England

Abstract

This paper explores how generalized trust develops over the life course among young people in England and whether trust is influenced more by family background factors or by conditions in late adolescence and early adulthood. If the latter are important, there may be reason for concern about falling levels of trust as material conditions, particularly regarding housing, have deteriorated for the present generation of young people. The first set of influences are highlighted by a perspective arguing that trust is primarily shaped by conditions in early childhood, while the latter are suggested by the so-called social learning perspective, which claims that people continuously adjust their social trust through interactions with people in different contexts. Analyzing data of the Citizenship Education Longitudinal Survey, the study finds that trust remains quite volatile until the early twenties. It declines between ages 16 and 23 and groups differing in educational attainment, civic participation and housing situation start to drift apart in their levels of trust between these ages. Educational attainment, civic participation and housing, as conditions pertaining to late adolescence and early adulthood, also turn out to have a significant impact on trust at age 23 controlling for trust at age 16. However, while the first two conditions are influenced by trust at age 16, housing (tenure) is not, indicating it is a more exogenous factor. Family background factors are not influential. Not only do these findings support the social learning perspective, they also suggest that poor living conditions depress trust among a significant minority of young people and exacerbate disparities of trust.

Young adults' personal concerns during the COVID-19 pandemic in Finland: an issue for social concern

“…According to many studies, generalized social trust (i.e., trust in people you do not know) is a key asset in social and economic life. It has been suggested that since the Great Recession of 2008 disproportionately affected young age groups by increasing their unemployment rate, for example, generalized trust among young people declined in many European countries (e.g., Ervasti et al, 2019;Janmaat, 2019). As opposed to particularized trust (i.e., trust among family, friends, and colleagues), generalized trust is directed outward, enhancing interconnection with a wide variety of people (Stolle, 2002;Uslaner, 2002).…”

“…It has been suggested that since the Great Recession of 2008 disproportionately affected young age groups by increasing their unemployment rate, for example, generalized trust among young people declined in many European countries (e.g. Ervasti et al, 2019;Janmaat, 2019). As opposed to particularized trust (i.e.…”

Changing social and political attitudes in Ireland and Northern Ireland

“…Studies have shown that, at the societal level, higher generalised trust is associated with multiple positive outcomes, including economic growth, government performance, and the support and maintenance of the state welfare system (Putnam, 2000;Rothstein, 2001;Uslaner, 2002;Nannestad, 2008). Among individuals, it is frequently associated with higher wellbeing, social integration, volunteering, the provision of public goods, and health (Kawachi, 1999;Putnam, 2000;Thöni et al, 2012;Sønderskov and Dinesen, 2016;Janmaat, 2019).…”

Neighborhood as a place to foster generalized trust among young adults in Hong Kong

“…The neighborhood behaviors of neighborhood social participation, such as participation in local affairs and numbers of neighborhood organizational memberships, is associated with higher levels of trust (e.g., Freitag & Traunmüller, 2009;Geys, 2012;Janmaat, 2019;Paxton, 2007;Sturgis et al, 2012;Wollebaek & Strømsnes, 2008). The LAI ET AL.…”

“…The neighborhood behaviors of neighborhood social participation, such as participation in local affairs and numbers of neighborhood organizational memberships, is associated with higher levels of trust (e.g., Freitag & Traunmüller, 2009; Geys, 2012; Janmaat, 2019; Paxton, 2007; Sturgis et al, 2012; Wollebæk & Strømsnes, 2008). The opportunity to have frequent social interactions in community associations allows the establishment of trust in strangers who also belong to the same community (Rocco & Suhrcke, 2012).…”