The Development of Public Policies to Address Non-communicable Diseases in the Caribbean Country of Barbados: The Importance of Problem Framing and Policy Entrepreneurs

Abstract

Background: Government policy measures have a key role to play in the prevention and control of non-communicable diseases (NCDs). The Caribbean, a middle-income region, has the highest per capita burden of NCDs in the Americas. Our aim was to examine policy development and implementation between the years 2000 and 2013 on NCD prevention and control in Barbados, and to investigate factors promoting, and hindering, success. Methods: A qualitative case study design was used involving a structured policy document review and semi-structured interviews with key informants, identified through stakeholder analysis and ‘cascading.’ Documents were abstracted into a standard form. Interviews were recorded, transcribed verbatim and underwent framework analysis, guided by the multiple streams framework (MSF). There were 25 key informants, from the Ministry of Health (MoH), other government Ministries, civil society organisations, and the private sector. Results: A significant policy window opened between 2005 and 2007 in which new posts to address NCDs were created in the MoH, and a government supported multi-sectoral national NCD commission was established. Factors contributing to this government commitment and funding included a high level of awareness, throughout society, of the NCD burden, including media coverage of local research findings; the availability of policy recommendations by international bodies that could be adopted locally, notably the framework convention on tobacco control (FCTC); and the activities of local highly respected policy entrepreneurs with access to senior politicians, who were able to bring together political concern for the problem with potential policy solutions. However, factors were also identified that hindered multi-sectoral policy development in several areas, including around nutrition, physical activity, and alcohol. These included a lack of consensus (valence) on the nature of the problem, often framed as being predominantly one of individuals needing to take responsibility for their health rather than requiring government-led environmental changes; lack of appropriate detailed policy guidance for local adaptation; conflicts with other political priorities, such as production and export of alcohol, and political reluctance to use legislative and fiscal measures. Conclusion: The study’s findings indicate mechanisms to promote and support NCD policy development in the Caribbean and similar settings.

Non-Communicable Diseases and Urbanization in African Cities: A Narrative Review

“…Urban populations in Africa tend to be very diverse by education, religion, socioeconomic status and culture [5]. As a result, NCD prevention and control policies and programs need to be tailored to cater for variations at population levels [107]. In a review CVD policies in Kenya found no standalone policies for CVD management and care but some aspects of CVD policy were covered in general NCD policy document [108].…”

Policy entrepreneurship in developing countries: A systematic review of the literature

“…Most of the articles in our sample (82.6%) use a single case study analysis. Thus, comparative analysis is less common (for a comparative article, see Unwin, Samuels, Hassell, Brownson, & Guell, 2016), although they may add to our understanding of the phenomenon of policy entrepreneurship.…”

The significance of DOHaD for Small Island Developing States

“…NCDs and the SIDS environment are both complex, dynamic systems that together, present an even more multifaceted set of issues. 15,16 The Cynefin model of decision-making ( Fig. 1) highlights that is not enough to consider 'best practice' strategies in complex adaptive systems, as such strategies specify a simple cause and effect pathway, encouraging a reductionist view of complex issues, such as NCDs.…”