High-accuracy ab initio folding has remained an elusive objective despite decades of effort. To explore the folding landscape of villin headpiece subdomain HP35, we conducted two sets of replica exchange molecular dynamics for 200 ns each and three sets of conventional microsecond-long molecular dynamics simulations, using AMBER FF03 force field and a generalized-Born solvation model. The protein folded consistently to the native state; the lowest C␣-rmsd from the x-ray structure was 0.46 Å, and the C␣-rmsd of the center of the most populated cluster was 1.
Despite decades of effort, high-accuracy ab initio protein folding has remained elusive to the simulation community. Most existing ab initio protein folding simulations have typically been at the 3-4 Å level based on the best C ␣ -rmsd compared with the experimental structures. When heavy-atom rmsd is used, a much larger rmsd (Ͼ5 Å) would be common. Yet, crystals of small proteins that can diffract only at 5-Å resolution are not considered of acceptable quality. Thus, most of the ab initio folding simulations have never reached the native states despite the enormous effort, underscoring the challenge. Because of the lack of accuracy in those simulations, it is impossible to obtain the crucial information on the folding pathways to the native states. This renders great ambiguity to the interpretation of the folding mechanisms. In this work, we demonstrate consistent ab initio protein folding to the native state of HP35.Villin headpiece is an F actin-binding domain that resides in the far C terminal of the super villin (1, 2). The 35-residue C-terminal subdomain HP35 can fold autonomously without the assistance of disulfide bonds or metal ions and has a melting temperature of T m ϭ 342 K, which is surprisingly high for a protein of its size (3-5). HP35 is arguably the smallest native occurring protein with the features of much bigger proteins, where multiple secondary structures (three helices) are bound together by a well packed hydrophobic core (three phenylalanine residues and other hydrophobic residues). As such, unveiling the folding mechanism of HP35 will augment our understanding of protein folding.The unique structural architecture of HP35 was revealed by using both NMR and x-ray crystallography (5, 6). However, the elucidation of the folding mechanism of HP35, remains a long-standing endeavor. In a laser-induced temperature-jump experiment, the quenching of Trp 23 by the engineered His 27 revealed a 4.3-s fast folding (4), which was later confirmed by NMR line-shape analysis (7) and loop-formation dynamics (8).Two kinetic phases, with the time constant of 70 ns and 5 s, were observed experimentally (4), indicating hidden complexities in the folding process. Mutagenesis experiments on the three core phenylalanine residues (9) and the Pro 21 -X 22 -Trp 23 motif (10) demonstrated the contribution from interior and surface residues to the stability. Studies of the HP35 fragments showed that the individual helices are largely unstructured, whereas the frag...