The Eco-Scalar Fix: Rescaling Environmental Governance and the Politics of Ecological Boundaries in Alberta, Canada

Abstract

This paper engages with recent work in political ecology that explores the ways in which scale is imbricated in environmental governance. Specifically, we analyze the deployment of speciflc ecological scales as putatively 'natural' governance units in rescaling processes. To undertake this analysis, the paper brings two sets of literature into dialogue:(1) political ecology of scale and (2) political economy of rescaling, drawing on theories of uneven development. Building on this literature, we develop the concept of an ecoscalar flx and explore its analytical potential through a case study of the rescaling of water governance in Alberta, Canada. We argue that although the 'eco-scalar fix' is usually framed as an apolitical governance change-particularly through the framing of particular scales (ie, the watershed) as 'natural'-it is often, in fact, a deeply political move that reconfigures power structures and prioritizes some resource uses over others in ways that can entrench, rather than resolve, the crises it was designed to address. Moreover, we suggest that, although watershed governance is often discursively depicted as an environmental strategy (eg, internalizing environmental externahties by aligning decision making with ecological boundaries), it is often articulated with-and undertaken to address challenges that arise through-processes of uneven development.

A political–industrial ecology of water supply infrastructure for Los Angeles

“…Political ecologists have provided trenchant insights into the structures of power that shape relationships between nature, society, and technology (Birkenholtz, 2013;Heynen et al, 2006;Meehan, 2013b), and the scalar and geographic dimensions of environmental decision-making (Cohen and Bakker, 2013;Heynen, 2003;Lawhon and Patel, 2013). Extending these insights to approaches in industrial ecology, the field can provide important analyses to foster more sustainable and resilient futures.…”

The Molecular Turn in Conservation: Genetics, Pristine Nature, and the Rediscovery of an Extinct Species of Galápagos Giant Tortoise

“…The reconceptualizations of life associated with the molecular gaze (Franklin 2000;Keller 2000;Rose 2007) are also reshaping understandings of biodiversity and how to best "save" it (Takacs 1996). Geographers and political ecologists have recently highlighted the ways in which scientific knowledge shapes the scales and political debates of conservation management (Campbell 2007;Rangan and Kull 2009;Cohen and Bakker 2014). But the rich literature on genetics in critical geography focuses mainly on the politics of tracing human ancestry and the spread of diseases (Nash 2005(Nash , 2012(Nash , 2013Braun 2007;Livingstone 2010).…”

Rescaling Energy? Räumliche Neuordnungen in der deutschen Energiewende

“…Neben politökonomischen Anwendungsfeldern der ScaleTheorie wurde das Konzept in den letzten Jahren auf das Feld der Governance von Umwelt-und natürlichen Ressourcen übertragen (Bulkeley, 2005;Cohen und Bakker, 2014;Reed und Bruynell, 2010). Ausgangspunkt dieser Arbeiten ist häufig die fehlende Übereinstimmung zwischen politischadministrativen und naturräumlichen Maßstabsebenen, beispielsweise bei Wasserscheiden oder Nationalparks (Cohen und McCarthy, 2015).…”