The effect of bed roughness uncertainty on tidal stream power estimates for the Pentland Firth

Abstract

Uncertainty affects estimates of the power potential of tidal currents, resulting in large ranges in values reported for sites such as the Pentland Firth, UK. Kreitmair et al. (2019, R. Soc. open sci. 6 , 180941. ( doi:10.1098/rsos.191127 )) have examined the effect of uncertainty in bottom friction on tidal power estimates by considering idealized theoretical models. The present paper considers the role of bottom friction uncertainty in a realistic numerical model of the Pentland Firth spanned by different fence configurations. We find that uncertainty in removable power estimates resulting from bed roughness uncertainty depends on the case considered, with relative uncertainty between 2% (for a fully spanned channel with small values of mean roughness and input uncertainty) and 44% (for an asymmetrically confined channel with high values of bed roughness and input uncertainty). Relative uncertainty in power estimates is generally smaller than (input) relative uncertainty in bottom friction by a factor of between 0.2 and 0.7, except for low turbine deployments and very high mean values of friction. This paper makes a start at quantifying uncertainty in tidal stream power estimates, and motivates further work for proper characterization of the resource, accounting for uncertainty inherent in resource modelling.

Potential Environmental Effects of Marine Renewable Energy Development—The State of the Science

“…The effects modeled from very large arrays (1 GW or more) indicate the potential for substantial changes in the marine environment, although most are highly dependent on the device layout, channel geometry, habitat type, and flow patterns [103]. The process of modeling interactions of MRE devices with the ocean creates a level of uncertainty that may propagate through subsequent steps in estimating power outputs and effects [104]. It will also be important in the future to examine other forcing functions, such as climate change, to determine the potential effects of MRE devices on water flow, wave height, and sediment transport [105].…”

Spatio-temporal variability of tidal-stream energy in north-western Europe

“…bed roughness) and sources of data (e.g. bathymetry and boundary conditions) [24,32], predictions were assessed against available observations of tidal range and currents. We assumed here that the existing validations were sufficient to conduct a comparison of numerical predictions in the three tidal stream energy sites.…”

Turbulence characterization at a tidal energy site using large-eddy simulations: case of the Alderney Race

“…According to the measurements of [2], increasing turbulence intensity reduces the power and the thrust by over 10% in extreme cases. The turbulent effects have also been studied numerically in [4], where a horizontal axis tidal turbine operating over an irregular bathymetry has been simulated [5]. Those investigations confirmed that bedform-induced turbulence enhances wake deficit recovery.…”