The Effect of External Attentional Focus and Self-Controlled Feedback on Motor Learning in Older Adults

Abstract

Introduction. External focus instruction and self-controlled feedback have beneficial effects on motor learning. The purpose of the present study was to investigate the benefits of combined effects of external focus instruction and self-controlled feedback on balance performance in older adults.Material and Methods. Forty older adults (mean age: 63.21 ± 3.6 years; all female) were selected and randomly divided into 4 groups: self-controlled feedback, external attention, external attention/self-controlled feedback and control group. The task of standing on the platform of the stabilometer device and trying to keep the platform horizontally as much as possible was performed in each 30-sec. trial. The participants of self-controlled group received feedback on the timing of balance after the trials. In the external focus of attention, participants noticed the signs that were located horizontally ahead of their feet. The test was conducted in two sessions. In the acquisition phase, 10 trials of 30 seconds were performed and the retention test was completed 24 hours later as 5 trials of 30 seconds.Results. The results of mixed ANOVA on time data as an indicator of balance in the acquisition phase showed that the mixed group of external focus of attention and self-controlled feedback had better performance than the other groups (p = 0.004). In the retention test, the results of mixed ANOVA showed that the participants in the combined group of external focus and self-controlled feedback had better performance than the other groups (p = 0.006). The external focus of attention and self-controlled feedback performed similarly, and both were superior to the control group (p < 0.05).Conclusions. The results of this study, supporting the OPTIMAL theory of motor learning in the elderly, showed that the combination of two factors of external focus and self-controlled feedback has a double advantage over the presence of each of the factors. Therefore, it is suggested that the combinations of external focus instructions and self-controlled feedback should be used to improve performance and motor learning in the classes of practical and clinical rehabilitation fields.

Motor learning and working memory in children: The role of cognitive-motor and motor-motor dual-task training

“…Under dual-task conditions, due to simultaneously concentrating on primary and secondary tasks, individuals may automatically shift their attention to external cues. A large body of the existing studies confirms that using external focus of attention results in a greater improvement in motor, and even cognitive, learning and functions, including working memory, compared to cases where internal focus of attention is used (Razaghi et al, 2020;Wulf, 2013). In this regard, Wulf et al, (2013) put forth the constrained action hypothesis, arguing that, while using external attention, individuals improve their motor learning and performance through facilitating automatic processes in their motor systems while in cases where the external focus of attention is employed, learners often disrupt these automatic processes, undermining their motor performances.…”

An external focus of attention enhances table tennis backhand stroke accuracy in low-skilled players

“…Thus, future studies are recommended to analyze the impact of internal and external (proximal and distal) attentional focus while using other strokes in table tennis. What is more, Razaghi et al [ 42 ] suggest that the combinations of external focus instructions and self-controlled feedback should be used to improve performance and motor learning outcomes. Also, Makaruk et al [ 43 ] propose that a combination of external attentional focus with autonomy support may produce benefits in motor performance.…”

The Effects of Holistic, External, and Internal Attentional Focus Instructions on Power and Kinematics of the Hang Power Snatch in Highly Skilled Weightlifters

“…Research has largely demonstrated that focusing outside the body and on the intended outcome of the movement (i.e., external focus) yields better results in learning and movement performance than focusing on body parts, specific movements, or mechanics (i.e., internal focus) ( Neumann, 2019 ). External attentional focus has been shown to result in increased movement efficiency (e.g., reduced muscle activity, higher peak force), movement performance (e.g., better balance, greater accuracy, greater speed, better endurance), a better movement form, as well as more automatic and fluent movements ( Artymiak et al, 2017 ; Razaghi et al, 2020 ; Wulf and Lewthwaite, 2016 ).…”