The Effect of Position on Radiographic Angle Measurements of the Lower Extremities

Abstract

Purpose. Accurately measuring an angle on a lower extremity X-ray is essential for the diagnosis and treatment of knee osteoarthritis (KOA). However, the angle is often affected by position, especially with flexion contracture and rotation. To date, there have been no quantitative analyses examining the relationship between lower extremity angle and patient position and no studies targeting patients with deformities. The aim of this study is to quantify the effect of position on angle measurements in lower extremity X-rays and to compare the effect in patients with different deformities. Methods. Computed tomography (CT) data of 131 patients with knee pain were retrospectively analyzed. The subjects were categorized into the following groups: neutral (hip-knee-ankle angle (HKAA) between 175 and 185°), varus (HKAA less than 175°), valgus (HKAA more than 185°), and flexion (flexion contracture more than 10°). CT images were digitally reconstructed to anterior-posterior X-ray images using an average intensity projection algorithm. The process was then repeated while rotating the reconstruction plane from internal 9° to external 9°. In this manner, X-ray images were reconstructed in different rotational states. The following angles were measured from reconstructed X-ray images: HKAA, lateral distal femoral angle (LDFA), medial proximal tibial angle (MPTA), and femoral valgus angle (FVA). The measurements were then compared according to the degree of rotation. Results. FVA significantly differed according to rotation in all groups ( P < 0.001 ), with a difference of 1.3° (±0.4°). HKAA significantly changed only in the flexion contracture group ( P < 0.001 ), which showed a difference of 1.0° (±0.7°). However, HKAA in the other groups, LDFA, and MPTA did not significantly differ depending on rotation. Conclusions. Radiographic measurement of FVA is subject to change according to rotation. HKAA significantly changed only in the flexion contracture group, so more care should be taken while obtaining X-rays of patients with flexion contracture.

Strong Correlation Between Standing Long-Leg Radiographs and CT Scans in Measuring Coronal Knee Alignment

“…Two centers utilized conventional radiography to make the LLRs, whereas the third employed the EOS 3D biplanar lowdose imaging system (EOS Imaging). Given our secondary aims to identify variables that had the potential to be associated with greater discrepancies between the 2 imaging modalities and to emulate pragmatic practice when conducting the CT scan, we endeavored to adjudicate the rotation of the lower limb 8 .…”