The effect of social media on well-being differs from adolescent to adolescent

Abstract

The question whether social media use benefits or undermines adolescents' well-being is an important societal concern. Previous empirical studies have mostly established across-the-board effects among (sub)populations of adolescents. As a result, it is still an open question whether the effects are unique for each individual adolescent. We sampled adolescents' experiences six times per day for one week to quantify differences in their susceptibility to the effects of social media on their momentary affective well-being. Rigorous analyses of 2,155 real-time assessments showed that the association between social media use and affective well-being differs strongly across adolescents: While 44% did not feel better or worse after passive social media use, 46% felt better, and 10% felt worse. Our results imply that person-specific effects can no longer be ignored in research, as well as in prevention and intervention programs. Ever since the introduction of social media, such as Facebook and Instagram, researchers have been studying whether the use of such media may affect adolescents' well-being. These studies have typically reported mixed findings, yielding either small negative, small positive, or no effects of the time spent using social media on different indicators of well-being, such as life satisfaction and depressive symptoms (for recent reviews, see for example 1-5). Most of these studies have focused on between-person associations, examining whether adolescents who use social media more (or less) often than their peers experience lower (or higher) levels of well-being than these peers. While such between-person studies are valuable in their own right, several scholars 6, 7 have recently called for studies that investigate within-person associations to understand whether an increase in an adolescent's social media use is associated with an increase or decrease in that adolescent's well-being. The current study aims to respond to this call by investigating associations between social media use and well-being within single adolescents across multiple points in time 8-10. Person-specific effects. To our knowledge, four recent studies have investigated within-person associations of social media use with different indicators of adolescent well-being (i.e., life satisfaction, depression), again with mixed results 6, 11-13. Orben and colleagues 6 found a small negative reciprocal within-person association between the time spent using social media and life satisfaction. Likewise, Boers and colleagues 12 found a small within-person association between social media use and increased depressive symptoms. Finally, Coyne and colleagues 11 and Jensen and colleagues 13 did not find any evidence for within-person associations between social media use and depression. Earlier studies that investigated within-person associations of social media use with indicators of well-being have all only reported average effect sizes. However, it is possible, or even plausible, that these average withinperson effects may have been small and...

Browsing Different Instagram Profiles and Associations With Psychological Well-Being

“…Media effects theorists argue that the influence of the media may depend on individual and situational characteristics (Valkenburg and Peter, 2013;Beyens et al, 2020). The current research considers two individual differences that are relevant for emerging adult development, but have yet to be experimentally explored as moderators in the link between passive browsing and well-being: feedback seeking and the fear of missing out (FoMO).…”

Social Media Use and Depressive Symptoms—A Longitudinal Study from Early to Late Adolescence

“…Since social media and the way that adolescents use it are changing constantly, the measures to be used in future studies should be more precise, ideally objective. Future studies could examine, for instance, how these longitudinal associations translate into short-term effects with data derived via experience sampling method or ecological momentary assessment [ 75 , 76 ].…”

Social media and smartphone app use predicts maintenance of physical activity during Covid-19 enforced isolation in psychiatric outpatients

“…If and how this pattern varies across these important between-subjects dimensions should be addressed in future research. Further, by focusing on total daily time as the unit of analysis for smartphone use, we may be masking more fine-grained effects of application type and usage patterns—including differential effects of active communication/information-gathering and more passive browsing styles on mood [ 54 – 57 ]. Under our chosen analysis framework, effects that occur at faster timescale will be classified as contemporaneous effects, and effects which occur over substantially longer timescales may be incorporated into between-subjects variance [ 20 , 34 ].…”