The clonal anergy theory of induction of immunological tolerance states that differentiating B lymphocytes that encounter multivalent antigen at the pre-B to B cell transition stage can receive and store a negative signal, which renders them anergic to later triggering stimuli. The theory was tested by using an anti-IL chain monoclonal antibody, E4, as a model tolerogen.The fluorescence-activated cell sorter was used to select B cellfree cell populations from adult murine bone marrow or newborn spleen, and later, to analyze B cell neogenesis in vitro. The presence of E4 at 21 jg/ml was required to impede the development of normal numbers of B cells with full receptor status. The subsequent capacity of these B cells to respond in vitro to mitogens was assessed in a filler-cell free microculture system that allows single B cells to proliferate and differentiate. Concentrations of E4 far below those required to affect B cell neogenesis had profound inhibitory effects on the subsequent functional capacity of the B cells. In fact, 10-3 jig/ml of E4 markedly impaired both proliferation and antibody formation, and 10' jig/ml, which had no effect on Ig receptor development, abrogated functional ca- It is now well established that immature cells of the B lymphocyte lineage can be rendered immunologically tolerant by certain multivalent antigens both in vitro and in vivo (1-8). Recently, we provided evidence that the stage at which the cell displayed its greatest sensitivity to negative signaling was that of first emergence of the surface membrane immunoglobulin (mIg) receptors, that is, during the pre-B to B cell transition (7). It is possible to introduce tolerogens into the tissues of the developing fetus by transplacental transfer (6) and thus ensure interaction between lymphoid cells and tolerogen at the first appearance of specific antigen binding receptors. When fluoresceinated human gamma globulin (FLU-HGG) was injected into mice at 14.5 days ofgestation, effective B cell tolerance was induced with doses far lower than those required to reduce the number of FLU-specific antigen-binding B cells in the offspring (8). In other words, B lymphocytes expressing a normal range of FLU-binding avidities appeared to emerge from the pre-B cell pool in normal numbers, but were incapable of giving rise to anti-FLU antibody-forming cell (AFC) clones when challenged with a B cell mitogen or a T lymphocyte-independent antigen. This suggested that interaction between the newly emerged anti-FLU receptors and antigen had neither impeded the subsequent development of a standard complement of mIg nor directly led to the death of the anti-FLU B cell. Rather, the cell, though still alive and capable ofbinding antigen, appeared to have received some signal rendering it incapable of responding to appropriate triggering stimuli. We termed this phenomenon clonal anergy.This conclusion was dependent on a technology that enumerated and characterized FLU-binding B cells, by counting cells adhering specifically to thin layers of hapten...