ABSTRACIrThe mechanisms of Al rhizotoxicity are not known, but disruption of membrane function has been a persistent hypothesis. The objective of this study was to establish whether cells of Al-cultured wheat roots (Triticum aestivum L. cv Tyler) exhibiting severe Al toxicity symptoms were capable of vigorous proton extrusion. The membrane electrical potential difference (Em) was measured in individual cells throughout the first centimeter of root tips during perfusion with Al solutions similar to or more concentrated than those of the culture medium. For both Alcultured and control roots the resting Em was -100 millivolts, and 1 millimolar acetic acid induced cyanide-sensitive hyperpolarizations to -180 millivolts at a maximum rate of -30 millivolts per minute. Al, like Ca2", enhanced the negativity of the Em of cells already treated with acetic acid. Both acetic acid and fusicoccin stimulated net proton extrusion from Al-cultured and control roots, both of which also extruded protons in the absence of these stimulants. These results demonstrate that wheat roots exhibiting severe Al toxicity symptoms had an undiminished capacity to extrude protons, that the membranes were intact, and that ATP synthesis was sufficient to supply the proton-translocating ATPases.Al"3 is a rhizotoxic ion that is often present in acidic soils at activities sufficiently high to seriously inhibit root elongation (32). At least one unstable polynuclear hydroxy-Al species is even more toxic than Al3" (20), but its presence in soils has not been confirmed. The mononuclear hydroxy-Al species, which are in equilibrium with Al3", are probably nontoxic (20), and some other Al complexes are demonstrably nontoxic (3, 11, 24). Since no Al species of charge < +3 has been shown to be toxic, Al rhizotoxicity may simply be an instance ofthe apparently general rhizotoxicity of polyvalent cations (4,20).These considerations bear upon the unelucidated mechanisms of Al toxicity. It is unknown whether the primary lesion is intracellular or extracellular, but according to equilibrium computations the cytoplasmic levels of OH-and other ligands for Al would reduce A13+ to an extremely small fraction of the intracellular Al (14). An intracellular lesion is also hard to reconcile with the nontoxicity of AlSO4+ (11) and other species which would also quickly respeciate intracellularly and therefore be indistinguishable from Al3+. Perhaps the polyvalent cations are the only species of Al to enter the cell, but that contradicts the general principle that membranes are more permeable to ions of lower charge (18). Nevertheless, hypotheses for an intracellular lesion have been advanced (16,19,21), and the differences in varietal sensitivity to Al have been considered in terms of Al exclusion by plasma membranes (29) or intracellular detoxification by Al- binding organic ligands (1, 24).The alternative view-that the primary lesion is extracellular-is easier to reconcile with the general rhizotoxicity of polyvalent cations, some ofwhich are reportedly impermeant, at...