The effects of confrontation and avoidance coping in response to workplace incivility.

Abstract

Workplace incivility has significant adverse consequences for targets. However, we know remarkably little about how targets of incivility cope and even less about which coping strategies are effective. Drawing on the coping process of the transactional model of stress, we examine confrontation as a form of problem-focused coping and avoidance as a form of emotion-focused coping in response to incivility. We examine the effects of these coping strategies on reoccurrence of incivility, incivility enacted by targets, psychological forgiveness, and emotional exhaustion. Focusing on the target's perspective of a series of uncivil interactions between a target and perpetrator, we conducted a 3-wave study of employees from various occupations. Employing the critical incident technique, participants reported on an incident of workplace incivility, and then answered a series of questions over 3 waves of data collection regarding their interactions with this perpetrator. Our findings suggest that confrontation and avoidance are ineffective in preventing reoccurrence of incivility. Avoidance can additionally lead to increased emotional exhaustion, target-enacted incivility, and lower psychological forgiveness. However, confrontation coping has promise with regards to eliciting positive outcomes such as psychological forgiveness that are beneficial to interpersonal workplace relationships. (PsycINFO Database Record

A Multicenter Study into Burnout, Perceived Stress, Job Satisfaction, Coping Strategies, and General Health among Emergency Department Nursing Staff

“…The use of avoidance coping may be explained by the low level of personal suffering due to the high turnover rate occurring in EDs [56]. In the multivariate analysis, EE and DP were determined positively by the use of avoidance coping, which was consistent with the findings of other authors [69,70]. It should be noted that some authors have long argued that the DP dimension is in fact a coping style [71,72].…”

Actively Coping with Violation: Exploring Upward Dissent Patterns in Functional, Dysfunctional, and Deserted Psychological Contract End States

“…Problem-focused coping encompasses actions that strive to eliminate an issue or reduce its effect (Tomprou et al, 2015; Hershcovis et al, 2017). Examples include “speaking up or acting to solve the problem and seeking advice or other instrumental aid” (Tomprou et al, 2015, p. 8).…”

Observers’ reactions to workplace incivility in the masculine domain: How does role congruency explain gender bias in future workers?

“…Consistent with similar studies (i.e., Chui & Dietz, 2014;Heilman & Okimoto, 2007;Hershcovis, Cameron, Gervais & Bozeman, 2018;, researchers instructed the participants to read one online scenario describing an episode of workplace incivility by a leader toward a subordinate in the male dominated field of information and communications technology (ICT). In engineering, women are underrepresented and young people's stereotypical gender beliefs about this occupation emerge (Heilman & Eagly, 2008;S ainz, Meneses, L opez & F abregues, 2016).…”