“…Previous researchers that found a positive influence between ESG performance on economic were Ferreroferrero et al, (2016), Signes, Ona, Jimenez, & Vargas (2013), Michelon, Boesso, & Kumar (2013), Roman, Hayibor, &Agle (1999), Simpson & Kohers (2002), Orlitzky, Schmidt, Rynes, &Rynes (2000), and Al-tuwaijri& Ii (2003). Meanwhile, studies that found negative results were Crisostomo, Freire, & Vasconcellos (2011).Other studies from Tarmuji, Maelah, & Tarmuji(2016), Dahlberg & Wiklund (2018), Waworuntu, Wantah, & Rusmanto (2014), Long, Bakhtiar, Chuann, Abdullah, & Mohammad (2017), and Velte (2018) found mixed results with the different object and variables.…”