The Effects of Gender Stereotypic and Counter-Stereotypic Textbook Images on Science Performance

Abstract

We investigated the effect of gender stereotypic and counter-stereotypic images on male and female high school students' science comprehension and anxiety. We predicted stereotypic images to induce stereotype threat in females and impair science performance. Counter-stereotypic images were predicted to alleviate threat and enhance female performance. Students read one of three chemistry lessons, each containing the same text, with photograph content varied according to stereotype condition. Participants then completed a comprehension test and anxiety measure. Results indicate that female students had higher comprehension after viewing counter-stereotypic images (female scientists) than after viewing stereotypic images (male scientists). Male students had higher comprehension after viewing stereotypic images than after viewing counter-stereotypic images. Implications for alleviating the gender gap in science achievement are discussed.

The gender gap in mathematics achievement: Evidence from Italian data

“…Problem solving, class-discussions and investigative work and cognitive activation strategies have been found to improve girls" performances (Boaler 2002;Zohar and Sela 2003;OECD 2015). In addition, Boaler et al (2011) and Good, Woodzicka, and Wingfield (2010) show that girls" proficiency increases by using counter-stereotypic pictures with female scientists.…”

Autistic people’s perspectives on stereotypes: An interpretative phenomenological analysis

“…This can have negative consequences for people, including low self-esteem and a range of other psychological problems (Corrigan, Bink, Schmidt et al, 2016;Link, Struening and NeeseTodd, et al, 2001; see Livingston and Boyd, 2010, for a review). Further, stereotype threat, where individuals feel at risk of confirming negative stereotypes held about their group (Good, Woodzica and Wingfield, 2010) has also been found to have negative effects on people (see Lamont, Swift and Abrams, 2015 for a review; Silverman and Cohen, 2014). In summary, holding negative stereotypes towards autistic people may lead to negative consequences for autistic people which go beyond non-disclosure and delayed diagnosis to prejudiced attitudes, negative behaviour, self -stigmatisation and stereotype threat.…”

Informatinio Mąstymo Ugdymo Užduotys: Merginų Ir Vaikinų Sprendimų Analizė

“…Informatikai reikia matematinių ir techninių įgūdžių, o jų merginos paprastai turi mažiau (Su, R. ir kt., 2009). Stereotipai ir tradiciška mąs-tysena vaidina labai svarbų psichologinį vaidmenį, pavyzdžiui, kai kuriuos dalykus, būtent socialinius mokslus, merginos renkasi noriau ir dažniau, o tiksliuosius mokslus, informatiką ir inžineriją -vaikinai (Good, 2010).…”