Two experiments examined the effects of US priming/reinstatement treatments on pigeons' responding to a partially extinguished CS. In Experiment 1, the subjects were given autoshaping to a keylight paired with food, and then responding to the keylight was partially extinguished. The subjects were subsequently given four presentations of food, that is, US priming/reinstatement treatment, approximately 30 min prior to testing with the CS. In contrast to previous reports that have demonstrated a reinstatement-induced facilitation of performance in rats, the present results yielded an attenuation in conditioned responding following the US reinstatement treatment relative to responding by a control group that did not receive the reinstatement presentations. In Experiment 2 we sought to distinguish between a priming account and some of the alternative interpretations of the results of Experiment 1. The subjects were given autoshaping with two separately trained keylights, and then responding to the target CS was partially extinguished. Consistent with a priming interpretation of the previous finding, nonreinforced presentations of the nonextinguished keylight approximately 30 min prior to testing with the extinguished CS attenuated conditioned responding.Presentations of the unconditioned stimulus (US) following extinction of a CS-US association and prior to testing the conditioned stimulus (CS) have been shown to facilitate conditioned responding in such preparations as conditioned suppression (e.g., Bouton & Bolles, 1979;Rescorla, 1973) and conditioned taste aversion (Schachtman, Brown, & Miller , 1985). This procedure is often referred to as the US reinstatement procedure.Regardless of the theoretical account one adopts for the US reinstatement effects (see , e .g ., Bouton & Bolles, 1979;Rescorla, 1973Rescorla, , 1974 Schachtman et aI., 1985), it is noteworthy that little work has been reported that concerns reinstatement of an extinguished CS-US autoshaped association using pigeons. This is surprising considering the frequent use of pigeons in classical conditioning studies and the import attributed to the autoshaping procedure. The initial aim of the present research was to examine the effects of US reinstatement on appetiti ve associations in pigeons.
EXPERIMENT 1In Experiment 1, the pigeons were given autoshaping training and then extinction. The next day, the subject s were given presentations of the US 30 min prior to testing. These US reinstatement presentations may increase the associative strength of the conditioning context and enhance performance through summation of the context-US and CS-US associations (Bouton & Bolles, 1979). Since this effect may obscure the potential for observing a reinstatement effect due to other mechanisms, an attempt was made to limit the influence of associative summation by administering the reinstatement presentations in a radically dissimilar context from that used for training and testing.
MethodSubjects. The subjects were 12 adult pigeons (Columba ltvia; maintained at 8...