Islet transplantation can provide metabolic stability for patients with type 1 diabetes; however, more than one donor pancreas is usually required to achieve insulin independence. To evaluate possible mechanistic defects underlying impaired graft function, we studied five subjects at 3 months and four subjects at 12 months following intraportal islet transplantation who had received comparable islet equivalents per kilogram (12,601 ؎ 1,732 vs. 14,384 ؎ 2,379, respectively). Cpeptide responses, as measures of -cell function, were significantly impaired in both transplant groups when compared with healthy control subjects (P < 0.05) after intravenous glucose (0.3 g/kg), an orally consumed meal (600 kcal), and intravenous arginine (5 g), with the greatest impairment to intravenous glucose and a greater impairment seen in the 12-month compared with the 3-month transplant group. A glucose-potentiated arginine test, performed only in insulin-independent transplant subjects (n ؍ 5), demonstrated significant impairments in the glucose-potentiation slope (P < 0.05) and the maximal response to arginine (AR max ; P < 0.05), a measure of -cell secretory capacity. Because AR max provides an estimate of the functional -cell mass, these results suggest that a low engrafted -cell mass may account for the functional defects observed after islet transplantation. Diabetes 54:100 -106, 2005