“…Although some researchers have raised concerns with attempting to describe reinforcement in the absence of a contingency (see Carr, 1996; Poling & Normand, 1999; Staddon, 1992; Vollmer, 1999), the use of the term NCR and of such schedules to reduce aberrant or undesired behaviors have become commonplace (for reviews, see Carr et al, 2000; Ingvarsson & Fernandez, 2023). During the last couple of decades, applied research efforts involving response‐independent schedules with animals have emerged including with a black vulture ( Coragyps atratus ; Morris & Slocum, 2019), polar bears ( Ursus maritimus ; Fernandez, 2010; Fernandez, 2021), and domestic dogs ( Canis familiaris ; Hall et al, 2015; Pfaller‐Sadovsky et al, 2022; Protopopova & Wynne, 2015). Additionally, response‐independent schedules have been used as an experimental control procedure in applied animal behavior research, contrasting the effects of noncontingent food with food delivered contingent on specific approximation steps in a shaping program (Fernandez, 2020; Fernandez & Rosales‐Ruiz, 2020).…”