The Effects of Rock Index Tests on Prediction of Tensile Strength of Granitic Samples: A Neuro-Fuzzy Intelligent System

Abstract

Rock tensile strength (TS) is an essential parameter for designing structures in rock-based projects such as tunnels, dams, and foundations. During the preliminary phase of geotechnical projects, rock TS can be determined through laboratory works, i.e., Brazilian tensile strength (BTS) test. However, this approach is often restricted by laborious and costly procedures. Hence, this study attempts to estimate the BTS values of rock by employing three non-destructive rock index tests. BTS predictive models were developed using 127 granitic rock samples. Since the simple regression analysis did not yield a meaningful result, the development of models that integrate multiple input parameters were considered to improve the prediction accuracy. The effects of non-destructive rock index tests were examined through the use of multiple linear regression (MLR) and adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system (ANFIS) approaches. Different strategies and scenarios were implemented during modelling of MLR and ANFIS approaches, where the focus was to consider the most important parameters of these techniques. As a result, and according to background and behaviour of the ANFIS (or neuro-fuzzy) model, the predicted values obtained by this intelligent methodology are closer to the actual BTS compared to MLR which works based on linear statistical rules. For instance, in terms of system error and a-20 index, values of (0.84 and 1.20) and (0.96 and 0.80) were obtained for evaluation parts of ANFIS and MLR techniques, which revealed that the ANFIS model outperforms the MLR in forecasting BTS values. In addition, the same results were obtained through ranking systems by the authors. The neuro-fuzzy developed in this study is a strong technique in terms of prediction capacity and it can be used in the other rock-based projects for solving relevant problems.

Computational Intelligence-Based Structural Health Monitoring of Corroded and Eccentrically Loaded Reinforced Concrete Columns

“…In the case of a perfect model with a zero-estimate error variance, the Nash-Sutclife efciency (NSE) equals one (NSE � 1) and vice versa. Te a-20 index is a recently introduced statistical engineering measure that can be used to evaluate AI models by displaying the number of samples that suit the estimation values with a 20% variance from experimental values [60][61][62]. R 2 , NS, and a-20 index values closer to 1 indicate the best correlation between the estimated and the experimental results.…”

Comparative analysis of various machine learning algorithms to predict 28-day compressive strength of Self-compacting concrete

“…The a20-index is also a very useful metric to assess the accuracy of ML models. It measures the proportion of predictions that deviate ±20 % from the predicted values [ 91 ]. It has been recommended in literature that for a perfect ML model, the a20-index value should be 1 [ 92 ].…”