The Efficacy of Resiliency Training Programs: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Trials

Abstract

ImportancePoor mental health places a burden on individuals and populations. Resilient persons are able to adapt to life’s challenges and maintain high quality of life and function. Finding effective strategies to bolster resilience in individuals and populations is of interest to many stakeholders.ObjectivesTo synthesize the evidence for resiliency training programs in improving mental health and capacity in 1) diverse adult populations and 2) persons with chronic diseases.Data SourcesElectronic databases, clinical trial registries, and bibliographies. We also contacted study authors and field experts.Study SelectionRandomized trials assessing the efficacy of any program intended to enhance resilience in adults and published after 1990. No restrictions were made based on outcome measured or comparator used.Data Extraction and SynthesisReviewers worked independently and in duplicate to extract study characteristics and data. These were confirmed with authors. We conducted a random effects meta-analysis on available data and tested for interaction in planned subgroups.Main OutcomesThe standardized mean difference (SMD) effect of resiliency training programs on 1) resilience/hardiness, 2) quality of life/well-being, 3) self-efficacy/activation, 4) depression, 5) stress, and 6) anxiety.ResultsWe found 25 small trials at moderate to high risk of bias. Interventions varied in format and theoretical approach. Random effects meta-analysis showed a moderate effect of generalized stress-directed programs on enhancing resilience [pooled SMD 0.37 (95% CI 0.18, 0.57) p = .0002; I2 = 41%] within 3 months of follow up. Improvement in other outcomes was favorable to the interventions and reached statistical significance after removing two studies at high risk of bias. Trauma-induced stress-directed programs significantly improved stress [−0.53 (−1.04, −0.03) p = .03; I2 = 73%] and depression [−0.51 (−0.92, −0.10) p = .04; I2 = 61%].ConclusionsWe found evidence warranting low confidence that resiliency training programs have a small to moderate effect at improving resilience and other mental health outcomes. Further study is needed to better define the resilience construct and to design interventions specific to it.Registration NumberPROSPERO #CRD42014007185

A longitudinal assessment of the road to mental readiness training among municipal police

“…Specifically, the research was designed to assess for changes in self-reported mental health symptoms, resilience, mental health awareness, work engagement, and mental health stigma attitudes over a one-year time frame. We expected that, consistent with prior reports (Leppin et al, 2014;Robertson et al, 2015), there would be small to moderate improvements in mental health stigma attitudes immediately after R2MR training and that the improvements would be sustained at 6-and 12-month follow-ups. In addition, we expected small to moderate improvements across all factors (mental health symptoms, mental health knowledge, resilience, work engagement) at 6-and 12-month follow-ups after R2MR training.…”

“…Resilience training programs are designed to sustain and protect employee well-being and performance in the face of adversity (Anderson, Vaughan, & Mills, 2017;Robertson, Cooper, Sarkar, & Curran, 2015). There have been two systematic reviews (Leppin et al, 2014;Robertson et al, 2015) evidencing the programs as having small to moderate effect sizes for improving resilience, mental health, and subjective well-being of participants (e.g. reductions in stress, symptoms of depression, negative affect).…”

The relationship between levels of resilience and coping styles in chiropractic students and perceived levels of stress and well-being

“…This suggests that an intervention aimed at enhancing resilience levels has the potential to effectively reduce stress levels and increase students' general psychologic well-being. 41 There are limitations to this study. This study engaged the majority of the chiropractic student cohort and provided broad insights into this population.…”

Resilience: Protective Factors for Depression and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder among African American Women?

“…To date there are a limited number of resilience-based intervention studies, particularly those conducted with diverse populations and in diverse settings. (Leppin et al, 2014) Poorer mental health among African American women may be mitigated by improving access to comprehensive, integrated and patient-centered quality health care. There should be better integration of screening to increase appropriate identification of mental illness, assessment, and support for African American women in a primary care clinic.…”