The ‘Empirical’ in the Empirical Turn: A Critical Analysis

Abstract

During the second half of the twentieth century, several philosophers of technology argued that their predecessors had reflected too abstractly and pessimistically on technology. In the view of these critics, one should study technologies empirically in order to fully understand them. They developed several strategies to empirically inform the philosophy of technology and called their new approach the empirical turn. However, they provide insufficient indications of what exactly is meant by empirical study in their work. This leads to the critical question of what counts as an empirically informed philosophy of technology in the empirical turn. In order to answer this question, we first elaborate on the problems that the empirical turn philosophers tried to address; secondly, we sketch their solutions, and, thirdly, we critically discuss their conceptions of empirical study. Our critical analysis of the empirical turn contributes to new efforts to engage in an empirically informed philosophy of technology.

Towards feminist health empowerment for self-testing apps : testing for dementia

“…Merging philosophical analysis with (a form of) empirical studies has been paramount in philosophy of technology since the "empirical turn", as explained in the theory chapter. However, the empirical turn has not resulted in a unified conception of what the "empirical" means for the organization of studies in philosophy of technology (Bosschaert & Blok, 2022). Some scholars engage in "empirical philosophy" in the sense that they use qualitative methods, while others content themselves with the description of case studies for "empiricallyinformed philosophy".…”

Philosophy of technology in the digital age : The datafication of the World, the homo virtualis, and the capacity of technological innovations to set the World free

“…Since my dissertation in 2005 (Blok, 2005), I have written extensively about philosophical method and currently. I am working on the development of a methodology for the philosophy of technology to research both levels of analysis in an integrated manner (Bosschaert and Blok, 2023).…”