The Empirical Reality of IT Project Cost Overruns: Discovering A Power-Law Distribution

Abstract

If managers assume a normal or near-normal distribution of Information Technology (IT) project cost overruns, as is common, and cost overruns can be shown to follow a power-law distribution, managers may be unwittingly exposing their organizations to extreme risk by severely underestimating the probability of large cost overruns. In this research, we collect and analyze a large sample comprised of 5,392 IT projects to empirically examine the probability distribution of IT project cost overruns. Further, we propose and examine a mechanism that can explain such a distribution. Our results reveal that IT projects are far riskier in terms of cost than normally assumed by decision makers and scholars. Specifically, we found that IT project cost overruns follow a power-law distribution in which there are a large number of projects with relatively small overruns and a fat tail that includes a smaller number of projects with extreme overruns. A possible generative mechanism for the identified power-law distribution is found in interdependencies among technological components in IT systems. We propose and demonstrate, through computer simulation, that a problem in a single technological component can lead to chain reactions in which other interdependent components are affected, causing substantial overruns. What the power law tells us is that extreme IT project cost overruns will occur and that the prevalence of these will be grossly underestimated if managers assume that overruns follow a normal or near-normal distribution. This underscores the importance of realistically assessing and mitigating the cost risk of new IT projects up front.

Reconfiguring European industry for net-zero: a qualitative review of hydrogen and carbon capture utilization and storage benefits and implementation challenges

“…Meanwhile, the overrun costs of megaprojects could amount to more than 45% of the initial budget. 164–167…”

“…Meanwhile, the overrun costs of megaprojects could amount to more than 45% of the initial budget. [164][165][166][167] The last political challenge dealt with geographic and geopolitical tensions, not only for potential impacts on local UK authorities, but also with regard to how the Ukrainian-Russia war influenced the development of the UK's industrial strategy. On the first theme, one expert suggested: ''I think some of this is a UK problem.…”

Why Digital Transformation May Fail – And What Can Be Done About It

“…The chances of success are slim at best however, with only 1 out of 8 digital transformation efforts likely to meet their stated objectives (Wade & Shan, 2020). Information technology projects more generally can put the organization at great risk through unpredictable, extreme cost overruns (Flyvbjerg et al, 2022).…”

The rationality of human behaviour and accuracy in information technology management

“…Business cases normally comprise estimations of the project cost, the post-project cost and the financial benefits (Keen [2012]). It is well recognised that project costs are not easy to estimate (Benschop et al [2020]; Flyvbjerg et al [2022]). Fewer insights are shared on the accuracy of completed business cases.…”

“…Nevertheless they include fifteen projects in their example and claim that 'more is better, so data from thirty projects beat data from fifteen'. This study uses a larger data set because larger data sets increase the probability distribution data, which is especially relevant to IT projects because their project expenses have been shown to be fat-tailed (Flyvbjerg et al [2022]). Nevertheless, gathering the data through expert interviews was impractical due to the magnitude of the data set needed to evaluate the hypotheses.…”