“…The timing of ocean closure varied from the late Devonian to the early Mesozoic (Chen et al, 2000;Xiao et al, 2003;Xu et al, 2013;Domeier & Torsvik, 2014;Zhang et al, 2015). Lots of papers (Xiao et al, 2003;Jian et al, 2010 ;Peng, Zhai, Li, & Ripley, 2013;Shang, 2004;Wang & Fan, 1997;Chu, Wei, Wang, & Ren, 2013;Li et al, 2014Li et al, , 2016aEizenhöfer et al, 2014Eizenhöfer et al, , 2015aEizenhöfer et al, , 2015bLi et al 2016a) have garnered support for the existence of oceanic basins during the late Carboniferous to the Permian and suggest a late Paleozoic to early-middle Triassic closure of the Paleo-Asian Ocean. However, based on the late Devonian unconformity and different deformation styles below and above the unconformity, Xu et al (2013) proposed that the Paleo-Asian Ocean closed during the late Devonian, followed by the Carboniferous-early Permian postcollisional thermal event, which led to the emplacement of bimodal volcanic rocks, alkaline granites, and gabbros (Tang et al, 2011a;Chen et al, 2012;Li et al, 2014;Tong et al, 2015;Zhao et al, 2016), and the continuous extension gave rise to the opening of a newly-born oceanic basins (Chen et al 2012;Zhang et al 2014a).…”