The Establishment of Catchment Management Agencies in South Africa with Reference to the Flussgebietsgemeinschaft Elbe: Some Practical Considerations

Abstract

The establishment of catchment management agencies goes beyond the involvement of governmental entities or the stipulations contained in regulatory structures and policies. A number of actors or stakeholders from both the governmental and non-governmental spheres are involved in establishing a CMA. Practices that are associated with CMA establishment often relate to personal experiences and the overall political landscape as well as administrative development trajectories. These are also context specifi c to the respective catchment. We refl ect on some of the administrative processes as a way to discern noticeable practices in the establishment of CMAs. Our case study material is the South African CMA establishment process to date. Some of the practices that come out strongly are human resource issues and fi nancial accounting practices that decision-makers need to consider when establishing CMAs. An appreciative relationship with key stakeholders, meeting them personally, is also crucial. The chapter is based on research commissioned and funded by South Africa's Water Research Commission between 2014 and 2016. The process of establishing the Flussgebietsgemeinschaft Elbe in Germany is also outlined to illustrate the similarities and differences in the experience of establishing a river basin organisation in a developed and developing country.

Lessons from community participation in primary health care and water resource governance in South Africa: a narrative review

“…For example, Some stakeholders in CMAs purposefully concealed information for their gain. [ 55 , 57 , 58 ]. In four WUAs and two CMAs, the language of communication was not an issue as most marginalized community representatives were able to communicate efficiently in Afrikaans, which was used as the bridging language, together with English [ 44 , 45 , 49 ].…”

Reflections On The Framework Of Water Governance In South Africa

“…DWS 2014b; Minister of Water Affairs 2015). To date, only 2 of the formerly 19 and now 9 Catchment Management Agencies (CMAs) are operating, and those 2 that are operating are facing huge challenges due to moving goal posts, financial uncertainty, and reorganization (Meissner, Stuart‐Hill & Nakhooda 2017). Although data and information are meant to be accessible to anyone, the reality is very different.…”

Enabling institutional environments conducive to livelihood improvement and adapted investments in sustainable land and water uses

“…Currently, seven of the nine CMAs are in the process of being established. These proto-CMAs are managed by the respective regional offices of the DWS (Meissner, Stuart-Hill and Nakhooda, 2017).…”