The ethnic density effect in psychosis: a systematic review and multilevel meta-analysis

Abstract

Background An ‘ethnic’ or ‘group’ density effect in psychosis has been observed, whereby the risk of psychosis in minority group individuals is inversely related to neighbourhood-level proportions of others belonging to the same group. However, there is conflicting evidence over whether this effect differs between minority groups and limited investigation into other moderators. Aims To conduct a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis of the group density effect in psychosis and examine moderators. Method Four databases were systematically searched. A narrative review was conducted and a three-level meta-analysis was performed. The potential moderating effect of crudely and specifically defined minority groups was assessed. Country, time, area size and whether studies used clinical or non-clinical outcomes were also tested as moderators. Results Thirty-two studies were included in the narrative review and ten in the meta-analysis. A 10 percentage-point decrease in own-group density was associated with a 20% increase in psychosis risk (OR = 1.20, 95% CI 1.09−1.32, P < 0.001). This was moderated by crudely defined minority groups (F6,68 = 6.86, P < 0.001), with the strongest associations observed in Black populations, followed by a White Other sample. Greater heterogeneity was observed when specific minority groups were assessed (F25,49 = 7.26, P < 0.001). Conclusions This is the first review to provide meta-analytic evidence that the risk of psychosis posed by lower own-group density varies across minority groups, with the strongest associations observed in Black individuals. Heterogeneity in effect sizes may reflect distinctive social experiences of specific minority groups. Potential mechanisms are discussed, along with the implications of findings and suggestions for future research.

The effects of social isolation stress and discrimination on mental health

“…Discrimination and a lack social support can also contribute to the increased risk of psychosis for individuals with a visible minority status (e.g., African and Caribbean communities in England) [113][114][115]. This effect may be particularly strong when there is perceived social isolation due to low community support from equally afflicted persons, e.g., due to so-called low "ethnic density" [116]. Such effects of local social support have also been described with respect to affective disorders, however, the effect of ethnic density on depression appeared more heterogenous, possibly due to potentially confounding effects of local poverty and socioeconomic disadvantage [117][118][119].…”

Effect Evaluation of Multilevel Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation Mechanism Combined with Multimedia Teaching on the Cultivation of Comprehensive Quality of Vocational Students

“…To this end, relevant central ministries and commissions jointly launched a major measure of quality education-the Quality Development Plan for College Students [10]. At present, this plan has been piloted in more than 100 universities across the country [11]. Such a quality development plan for college students, correctly understanding the connotation of quality education and objectively evaluating the First Middle School has become a common concern of all colleges and universities [12].…”

Scaling-up Child and Youth Mental Health Services: Assessing Coverage of a County-Wide Prevention and Early Intervention Initiative During One Fiscal Year

“…Higher ethnic density in communities has been found to be a protective factor for mental health (Bécares et al, 2018 ). Living in higher own-group communities can attenuate the impact of racism and discrimination and bolster social capital and its benefits (Baker et al, 2021 ). It may be that there was lower coverage because these communities were buffering the need for mental health services.…”