The evidence for cognitive behavioural therapy in any condition, population or context: a meta-review of systematic reviews and panoramic meta-analysis

Abstract

The majority of psychological treatment research is dedicated to investigating the effectiveness of cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) across different conditions, population and contexts. We aimed to summarise the current systematic review evidence and evaluate the consistency of CBT's effect across different conditions. We included reviews of CBT randomised controlled trials in any: population, condition, format, context, with any type of comparator and published in English. We searched DARE, Cochrane, MEDLINE, EMBASE, PsycINFO, CINAHL, CDAS, and OpenGrey between 1992 and January 2019. Reviews were quality assessed, their data extracted and summarised. The effects upon health-related quality of life (HRQoL) were pooled, within-condition groups. If the across-condition heterogeneity was I2 < 75%, we pooled effects using a random-effect panoramic meta-analysis. We summarised 494 reviews (221 128 participants), representing 14/20 physical and 13/20 mental conditions (World Health Organisation's International Classification of Diseases). Most reviews were lower-quality (351/494), investigated face-to-face CBT (397/494), and in adults (378/494). Few reviews included trials conducted in Asia, South America or Africa (45/494). CBT produced a modest benefit across-conditions on HRQoL (standardised mean difference 0.23; 95% confidence intervals 0.14–0.33, I2 = 32%). The effect's associated prediction interval −0.05 to 0.50 suggested CBT will remain effective in conditions for which we do not currently have available evidence. While there remain some gaps in the completeness of the evidence base, we need to recognise the consistent evidence for the general benefit which CBT offers.

A trans-diagnostic cognitive behavioural conceptualisation of the positive and negative roles of social media use in adolescents’ mental health and wellbeing

“…This decision was driven by our primary aim of making the conceptualisation of maximum practical utility to clinicians working in mental health settings for young people. Thus, CBT has a strong evidence base supporting it, and has demonstrated great flexibility in its application to a wide range of mental health difficulties (Fordham et al, 2021), such that the approach has come to dominate mental health services, including in young people's services in the UK, as well as further afield. It is our hope that insights and approaches to emerge from the conceptualisation can be integrated easily into existing practices by clinicians currently working face-to-face with young people.…”

Internet-based treatment of depression and anxiety among migrants and refugees in Sweden

“…Cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) is to date the most widely studied form of psychotherapy overall (Fordham et al, 2021) and there is more evidence supporting it than any other kind of talk therapy (David et al, 2018). CBT can be said to be an umbrella term for a number of different treatments for different kinds of psychopathology (David et al, 2018) with the common aspect being that these treatments incorporate both behavioural and cognitive interventions (Brewin, 1996).…”

Staying Calm and Well in the Midst of the COVID-19 Storm: One University's Longitudinal Outcomes Evaluation of a Mental Health and Well-Being Webinar Series

“…Cognitive-behavioral skills and positive psychology tips were taught in week 1 Series One and week 2 Series Two, respectively. Cognitive-behavioral skills are rooted in cognitive behavioral therapy (the gold standard evidence-based treatment for depression and anxiety treatment) which focuses on how thoughts impact feelings and behaviors (i.e., the thinking/feeling/behaving triangle; David, Cristea, & Hoffman 2018;Fordham et al, 2021). Accordingly, participants were taught and then practiced how to identify their stressful events, how to recognize the negative thoughts that follow, and how to replace those negative thoughts with neutral or positive thoughts to ultimately change their behavior and emotional outcomes.…”