The Existence Value of a Distinctive Native American Culture: Survival of the Hopi Reservation

Abstract

We measure the value placed by the American public on ensuring the continued existence of the traditional Hopi culture and way of life at the Hopi Reservation in Arizona. The Hopi are the oldest living culture in the United States. The continued existence of the Reservation is threatened by depletion of the groundwater resource underlying the reservation. In the future, without a new source of water, the Hopi will run out of water to support the villages and continue their traditional Hopi agricultural practices. Many Hopi will have to move off the Reservation and give up their traditional culture and way of life. The Reservation will no longer serve as a permanent home for the Hopi Tribe. An expensive pipeline would be required to convey a new source of water to the Reservation, for which the Federal government might pay. The question is: would the expenditure by the federal government to convey water that would ensure the continued existence of the traditional Hopi culture at the Hopi Reservation be justified by the existence value of that culture to the American people? This paper describes the results of a study undertaken to measure that existence value. We show that a simple stated preference design, using only a single monetary amount, is sufficient to provide a bound.

‘I didn’t count “willingness to pay” as part of the value’: Monetary valuation through respondents’ perspectives

“…This is how social constructions have material implications. Similarly, when a monetary estimate is uncritically claimed to measure the ‘existence value’ of ‘an entire culture, religion, and way of life’ (that of the Hopi tribe in Arizona, US), as do Carson et al (2020: 936), this is not only insensitive; when this estimate is used in actual decision-making it can arguably be life-changing.…”

Household and behavioral determinants of indoor PM 2.5 in a rural solid fuel burning Native American community

“…Traditional homes were frequently built of rock and plastered with mud mortar and included packed dirt floors and roofing of traditional tuuma (dirt over brush or sticks). Some of these homes were built prior to 1100 AD based on archeological records of the area 14,15 . Most modern homes had concrete slab floors with frame or block walls and asphalt roofs.…”

“…of the area. 14,15 Most modern homes had concrete slab floors with frame or block walls and asphalt roofs. Modular/mobile homes were constructed in a factory and had air flowing under the structure, a metal exterior, coated with a sprayed insulation and finished with paneling and ceiling tile.…”

Economic Valuation of Reducing Submerged Marine Debris in South Korea

“…Thus, the estimates for τ 0 and were obtained by maximizing Equation (3). In addition, the mean WTP was derived from Equation ( 2) as [44,45]:…”