The extended predicative Mahlo universe in Martin-Löf type theory

Abstract

This paper addresses the long-standing question of the predicativity of the Mahlo universe. A solution, called the extended predicative Mahlo universe, has been proposed by Kahle and Setzer in the context of explicit mathematics. It makes use of the collection of untyped terms (denoting partial functions) which are directly available in explicit mathematics but not in Martin-Löf type theory. In this paper, we overcome the obstacle of not having direct access to untyped terms in Martin-Löf type theory by formalizing explicit mathematics with an extended predicative Mahlo universe in Martin-Löf type theory with certain indexed inductive-recursive definitions. In this way, we can relate the predicativity question to the fundamental semantics of Martin-Löf type theory in terms of computation to canonical form. As a result, we get the first extended predicative definition of a Mahlo universe in Martin-Löf type theory. To this end, we first define an external variant of Kahle and Setzer’s internal extended predicative universe in explicit mathematics. This is then formalized in Martin-Löf type theory, where it becomes an internal extended predicative Mahlo universe. Although we make use of indexed inductive-recursive definitions that go beyond the type theory $\mathbf {IIRD}$ of indexed inductive-recursive definitions defined in previous work by the authors, we argue that they are constructive and predicative in Martin-Löf’s sense. The model construction has been type-checked in the proof assistant Agda.