“…For example, in Sutherland's (1984) reconstruction of an independent BIIS, ice terminates at the eastern margin of the Wee Bankie, off the eastern Scottish coast (Figure 1), and, following Synge (1956) and Flinn (1967), parts of Caithness, Buchan and northern Lewis fall beyond its limits. These nonglaciated enclaves subsequently appeared in many published reconstructions of the north-eastern sector of the last BIIS (Bowen et al, 1986;Bowen, 1989;Nesje and Sejrup, 1988;Boulton et al, 1991;Ehlers and Wingfield, 1991;Lambeck, 1995;Bowen et al, 2002;, despite the evidence for them having been seriously questioned (Peacock, 1997;Hall and Bent, 1990;Hall, 1997;Whittington et al, 1998;Whittington and Hall, 2002), or refuted . Nunataks formerly identified in the NW Highlands and Outer Hebrides by Ballantyne et al (1998) lent support for a thin, low-profile ice sheet, but reinterpretation of the trimline evidence now indicates that the ice exceeded 900 m and 600 m in altitude over these areas respectively and that Scotland was completely buried beneath ice during the last glaciation (Ballantyne, 2010).…”