The Fifth Estate.

Abstract

BENJAMINFRANKLIN was not perhaps in all respects a paragon, but he was unquestionably a polygon-a plain figure with many sides and angles. There were not enough buttons on his black coat to tell off the multifarious aspects in which his complex personality was presented to the world. He was craftsman and tradesman; philosopher and publicist; diplomat, statesman, and patriot. And he was, withal, a very human being. What concerns us particularly on this occasion is the fact that he was at once philosopher and man of affairs. His remarkable career should refute forever the fallacy, which, unfortunately, still is current, that the man of science is temperamentally unfitted, for the practical business of life.At the time when Franklin was in England the British Parliament was assumed to be composed of representatives of three estates-the lords spiritual, the lords temporal, and the commons; but Edmund Burke, pointing to the Reporters' Gallery, said, "There sits a Fourth Estate, more important far than they all." No one at all familiar with the ubiquitous influence and all-pervading power of the press would today question the validity of Burke's appraisal. Even then, however, there was present in England, in the person of Benjamin Franklin, a prototype and exemplar of the membership of a Fifth Estate-an estate destined to play an even greater part than its predecessors in the remaking of the world. Its MembershipThis Fifth Estate is composed of those having the simplicity to wonder, the ability to question, the power to generalize, the capacity to apply. It is, in short, the company of thinkers, workers, expounders, and practitioners upon which the world is absolutely dependent for the preservation and advancement of that organized knowledge which we call Science, It is their seeing eye that discloses, as Carlyle said, "the inner harmony of things; wha,t Nature meant." It is they who bring the power and the fruits of knowledge to the multitude who are content to go through life without thinking and without questioning, who accept fire and the hatching of an egg, the attraction of a feather by a bit of amber, and the stars in their courses, as a fish accepts the ocean.The curious deterioration to which words are subject has left us with no term in good repute and common usage by which the members of the Fifth Estate may properly be characterized. Sophists are no longer distinguished for wisdom: they are now fallacious reasoners.Philosophers, who once claimed all knowledge for their province, are now content with speculative metaphysics. Scholars have become pupils. The absent-minded and myopic professor is a standardized property of the stage and screen.The expert, if not under a cloud, is at least standing in the shade. In •

Training the translational workforce: Expanding beyond translational research to include translational science

“…17 As Arthur D. Little stated nearly 100 years ago, "In the past the world suffered grievously from lack of knowledge; today it suffers from its rejection or misapplication." 18 Should training programs, then, teach translational research and translational science trainees not just to communicate and implement evidence-based information but also to combat health misinformation 19 and to explain the iterative and sometimes cyclical process of science?…”