The forgotten guidelines: cross-sectional analysis of participation in muscle strengthening and balance & co-ordination activities by adults and older adults in Scotland

Abstract

BackgroundIn 2011, the UK physical activity guidelines were updated to include recommendations for muscle strengthening and balance & coordination (at least two sessions of relevant activities per week). However, monitoring and policy efforts remain focussed on aerobic activity. This study aimed to assess differences by gender and age in the a) prevalence of muscle strengthening and balance & co-ordination guidelines, and b) participation in guideline-specific activities.MethodsThe sample for the muscle strengthening analyses was 10,488 adult (16–64 years) and 3857 older adult (≥65 years) 2012–2014 Scottish Health Survey respondents. The balance & co-ordination analyses used only the older adult responses. Differences by gender and (where possible) age in guideline prevalence and activity participation were assessed using logistic regression and t-tests.ResultsThirty-one percent of men and 24 % of women met the muscle strengthening guideline, approximately half that of published figures for aerobic physical activity. Nineteen percent of older men and 12 % of older women met the balance & co-ordination guidelines. The oldest age groups were less likely to meet both guidelines compared to the youngest age groups. Differences by gender were only evident for muscle strengthening: more men met the guidelines than women in all age groups, with the largest difference amongst 16–24 year olds (55 % men compared with 40 % women). Participation in relevant activities differed by gender for both guidelines. ‘Workout at gym’ was the most popular activity to improve muscle strength for men (18 % participated), while swimming was for women (15 % participated). Golf was the most popular activity to improve balance & co-ordination for older men (11 % participated) and aerobics was for older women (6 % participated). Participation decreased in most muscle strengthening activities for both men and women. One exception was golf, where participation levels were as high amongst older men as in younger age groups, although overall levels were low (3 % of all men).ConclusionsPhysical activity policy should aim to increase prevalence of these ‘forgotten’ guidelines, particularly amongst young women (for muscle strengthening) and older age groups (both guidelines). Gender and age participation differences should be considered when designing population-level interventions.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12889-016-3774-6) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Effectiveness of peers in delivering programs or motivating older people to increase their participation in physical activity: Systematic review and meta-analysis

“…A recent Australian national-representative sample study found only 5.5% of those aged 50 and over were meeting the recommended levels (Australian Government Department of Health, 2016) of muscle-strengthening activities per week (Bennie et al, 2016). Similar results have also been reported in Germany (Mayer et al, 2011), the United Kingdom (Strain, Fitzsimons, Kelly, & Mutrie, 2016) and…”

Health-enhancing physical activity in Germany: findings from a national sample of 24,016 adults

“…However, compared to aerobic MVPA, as with other countries [23,24,33], the promotion of MSE has been of limited focus in previous Germany public health promotion [9]. Importantly, our study showed that compared to those reporting insufficient aerobic MVPA, greater proportions report insufficient MSE (70.6% vs. 54.7%).…”

Adhering to the 2017 Dutch Physical Activity Guidelines: A Trend over Time 2001–2018

“…Furthermore, the questionnaire items allow us to gain insight in the relative contribution of specific activities. To our knowledge, only few studies had this opportunity [25]. As far as we know, we are the first to combine yearly time points to assess long-term trends in adhering to a physical activity guideline and addressing activities that underlie changes over time.…”