“… Calvert [1981] suggested that R ‐ X waves ducted in FAI would be readily detectable. Evidence of ducting has been observed in the ionosphere for L ‐ O and R ‐ X modes [see, e.g., Muldrew , 1963, 1967, 1980] and in the magnetosphere for whistlers [e.g., Angerami , 1970; Carpenter , 1981; Carpenter and Sulic , 1988]. Only a few percent N e enhancement is required for effective whistler ducting [e.g., Smith , 1961; Helliwell , 1965], and a similar N e depletion for L ‐ O and R ‐ X mode ducting [see, e.g., Muldrew , 1963, 1967; Platt and Dyson , 1989; Calvert , 1995].…”