The Fundamental Opposition of Plato and Aristotle

Frank, Erich

doi:10.2307/291434

Cited by 4 publications

(3 citation statements)

References 0 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…144-145, 5 Desenvolvemos esta questão no artigo (Mesquita, 2011b). Mas para outros estudos que, sob esse aspecto, embora com diferentes perspectivas, se aproximam da tese aqui defendida, veja-se Frank (1940) e Grene (1963, pp. 38-65).…”

Section: António Pedro Mesquitaunclassified

O platonismo de Aristóteles. Contributo para a reconsideração de um problema historiográfico

Mezquita¹

2013

Ecos De Filosofía Antigua

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

La impresión que ha causado en muchos estudiosos la contradicción entre la identidad filosófica de Aristóteles y la influencia de su largo discipulado en la Academia platónica, así como entre segmentos textuales de tratados en los que parece predominar uno u otro, ha llevado a algunos autores a considerar que El pensamiento aristotélico quedó suspendido de una especie de crucifixión por la pulsión antinómica de dos tendencias: la asclepiad, natural en él y responsable de su apego a lo singular y lo concreto, y la platónica, adquirida en su escolarización y que emerge a veces en los pasajes. de mayor intimidad contemplativa.

show abstract

Section: António Pedro Mesquitaunclassified

O platonismo de Aristóteles. Contributo para a reconsideração de um problema historiográfico

Mezquita¹

2013

Ecos De Filosofía Antigua

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…For a further elaboration of this theme, see Arlene Saxonhouse (1982). 5 Consider, for example, Erich Frank (1940), Harold Cherniss (1944), and Hans-Georg Gadamer (1980). For a suggestive exception see Helmut Flashar (1977).…”

Section: Preliminary Considerationsmentioning

confidence: 99%

Aristotle's Anticommunism

Dobbs¹

1985

American Journal of Political Science

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This essay examines Aristotle's critical review of Plato's Republic, the focus of which review is restricted, surprisingly, to Socrates' communistic political institutions; Aristotle hardly mentions any of the other important themes developed in the dialogue. For this reason commentators have charged Aristotle with misrepresenting Plato's intention. Against this view, the author finds in Aristotle's anticommunism the most incisive formulation of his political disagreement with Plato's Socrates. Communism will not promote the harmonious articulation of city and man, as Socrates suggest; rather, it undermines the integrity of the political community and precludes the proper development of the best human nature. Aristotle holds that communism thus disrupts the entelechies of both city and man. Modern critiques, by contrast, merely indicate the adverse effects of communism on economic productivity or efficiency. Thus Aristotle's anticommunism is seen to offer for our consideration a dimension of this important issue that is typically neglected in contemporary political argument.

show abstract

“…Numerical and mathematical processing skills has a long history from the ancient classical Greeks Plato, Aristotle Frank, Mendel [1] to the birth of modern psychology, with John Dewey [2], Conant [3], O'Shea [4], suggesting that children learn numerical concepts by reinforcement, not in an abstract way, by identifying similarities, differences of empirical individual units, forming general concepts. This essay follows through the recent evolution of neuroimaging studies debate, sets the theoretical context of three dominant theories that influenced the context of research tools/methods; and how neuroscientific research has contributed uniquely to the understanding of numerosity.…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%