The gilded path: capital, habitus and illusio in the fund management field

Abstract

PurposeThe fund management sector plays an important role in society. The sector exists in close proximity to the accounting profession and the concerns of the paper reflect themes discussed by accounting scholars, particularly financialization, inequality and life within elite professional service organizations.Design/methodology/approachThis is an interpretive study of the fund management field based in the UK. It is based on 32 semi-structured interviews with individuals with personal experience of the field, combined with reflections from the researcher's own experience as a practitioner within the field.FindingsThe paper describes the backgrounds and motivations of individuals entering the field, the recruitment processes through which they are admitted, and the different strategies used to gain admission to the field. It explores the habitus of successful professionals in the field and the effects of this habitus.Social implicationsAn important social implication of the paper is the problematization of the fund management industry's dislocation from broader society.Originality/valueBy identifying the different strategies employed by applicants from different backgrounds, it highlights the role of reflexive agency and the complicity between agent and field. Recognizing that professional fund management is organized as a game, it suggests that individuals are so committed to the game they know they are playing that they fail to realize that they are also drawn into a different game, namely the absorbing game of being a fund manager.

The Field of Investment Advice: The Social Forces That Govern Equity Analysts

“…Despite these efforts to identify heterogeneity on the sell-side, this area has not been fully captured nor theorized by existing research. These findings are also supported by research showing that other financial professionals present significant variance in how they perform their tasks, whether that be in fund management (Millar 2021), public accounting (Spence and Carter 2014) or tax (Gracia and Oats 2012). Similar to our assertion about the more complex nature of rationality and motivation among sell-side analysts, we believe that the complexity of the social environment in which analysts operate is likely to also be reflected in heterogeneity among these actors and that to understand them better we need to explore the forces underpinning and maintaining this heterogeneity.…”

Field, capital, and habitus: The impact of Pierre Bourdieu on bibliometrics

“…Emirbayer and Johnson (2008) and Malsch et al (2011) have effectively put to use this "conceptual triad" as a vantage point to gauge Bourdieu's impact on other fields (the field of organisational analysis and accounting, respectively). More recent studies (Doblytė, 2019;Millar, 2021) also employ this perspective of the triad. Similarly, the content analysis and the detailed reading of documents ground this section that focuses on how the key concepts in the triad field-capital-habitus have been used.…”