The Global Financial Crisis: U.S. Bankruptcies and Going-Concern Audit Opinions

Abstract

SYNOPSIS This study investigates whether auditors' going-concern modified opinion (GCO) decisions were less likely after the start of the recent “Global Financial Crisis” (GFC). Auditing regulators and the business press had complained that auditors did not provide adequate warning in their reports prior to many companies filing for bankruptcy during the GFC. Accordingly, we examine auditors' GCO opinions for financially stressed clients that subsequently entered into bankruptcy during the period from 2004 to 2010. We find that, after controlling for other factors related to GCOs, the propensity of auditors to issue a GCO prior to bankruptcy significantly increased after the onset of the GFC. Additional tests reveal similar results when we separately examine clients of the Big 4 and non-Big 4 firms, suggesting both sized firms significantly increased the likelihood of issuing a GCO to a subsequently bankrupt client after the start of the GFC. Our results should be of interest to regulators, investors, audit firms, academics, and standard setters as they evaluate U.S. auditor performance during the GFC, and in contemplation of changes to auditing standards as a result of the GFC.

Are going‐concern issues disclosed in audit reports associated with subsequent bankruptcy? Evidence from the United States

“…This is consistent with evidence from prior studies that auditors were much more likely to issue GCOs immediately after the enactment of SOX (Feldmann & Read, 2010;Geiger, Raghunandan, & Riccardi, 2014). This is consistent with evidence from prior studies that auditors were much more likely to issue GCOs immediately after the enactment of SOX (Feldmann & Read, 2010;Geiger, Raghunandan, & Riccardi, 2014).…”

“…Some prior studies show that the association between GCOs and bankruptcies vary over time (Feldmann & Read, 2010;Geiger et al, 2005Geiger et al, , 2014. Hence, we include four indicator variables as follows: …”

Explaining auditors’ propensity to issue going‐concern opinions in Australia after the global financial crisis

“…We model Type 2 misclassifications using a model adapted from Geiger et al (2014). This is clearly a most serious situation and of prime concern to auditors, regulators and users of financial statements.…”

Palestine Banks Sector Ability to Apply Credit Risk Management According to Basel III

“…Particularly since the past few years, following the financial and banking crises; beginning with the financial crisis in Mexico at the end of 1994 and early 1995, Passing by the financial crises in southeast Asia [2], Brazil, Russia and Turkey, and ending with the global financial crisis in 2008 [3,4]. The global financial crisis was the most critical crisis that influenced the global economy, especially finance and banking sectors [5][6][7].…”