The Healthy Activity Program (HAP), a lay counsellor-delivered brief psychological treatment for severe depression, in primary care in India: a randomised controlled trial

Abstract

SummaryBackgroundAlthough structured psychological treatments are recommended as first-line interventions for depression, only a small fraction of people globally receive these treatments because of poor access in routine primary care. We assessed the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of a brief psychological treatment (Healthy Activity Program [HAP]) for delivery by lay counsellors to patients with moderately severe to severe depression in primary health-care settings.MethodsIn this randomised controlled trial, we recruited participants aged 18–65 years scoring more than 14 on the Patient Health Questionnaire 9 (PHQ-9) indicating moderately severe to severe depression from ten primary health centres in Goa, India. Pregnant women or patients who needed urgent medical attention or were unable to communicate clearly were not eligible. Participants were randomly allocated (1:1) to enhanced usual care (EUC) alone or EUC combined with HAP in randomly sized blocks (block size four to six [two to four for men]), stratified by primary health centre and sex, and allocation was concealed with use of sequential numbered opaque envelopes. Physicians providing EUC were masked. Primary outcomes were depression symptom severity on the Beck Depression Inventory version II and remission from depression (PHQ-9 score of <10) at 3 months in the intention-to-treat population, assessed by masked field researchers. Secondary outcomes were disability, days unable to work, behavioural activation, suicidal thoughts or attempts, intimate partner violence, and resource use and costs of illness. We assessed serious adverse events in the per-protocol population. This trial is registered with the ISRCTN registry, number ISRCTN95149997.FindingsBetween Oct 28, 2013, and July 29, 2015, we enrolled and randomly allocated 495 participants (247 [50%] to the EUC plus HAP group [two of whom were subsequently excluded because of protocol violations] and 248 [50%] to the EUC alone group), of whom 466 (95%) completed the 3 month primary outcome assessment (230 [49%] in the EUC plus HAP group and 236 [51%] in the EUC alone group). Participants in the EUC plus HAP group had significantly lower symptom severity (Beck Depression Inventory version II in EUC plus HAP group 19·99 [SD 15·70] vs 27·52 [13·26] in EUC alone group; adjusted mean difference −7·57 [95% CI −10·27 to −4·86]; p<0·0001) and higher remission (147 [64%] of 230 had a PHQ-9 score of <10 in the HAP plus EUC group vs 91 [39%] of 236 in the EUC alone group; adjusted prevalence ratio 1·61 [1·34–1·93]) than did those in the EUC alone group. EUC plus HAP showed better results than did EUC alone for the secondary outcomes of disability (adjusted mean difference −2·73 [–4·39 to −1·06]; p=0·001), days out of work (−2·29 [–3·84 to −0·73]; p=0·004), intimate partner physical violence in women (0·53 [0·29–0·96]; p=0·04), behavioural activation (2·17 [1·34–3·00]; p<0·0001), and suicidal thoughts or attempts (0·61 [0·45–0·83]; p=0·001). The incremental cost per quality-adjusted life-year gained was $933...

Counselling for Alcohol Problems (CAP), a lay counsellor-delivered brief psychological treatment for harmful drinking in men, in primary care in India: a randomised controlled trial

“…Another strength was that intensive assessments were not done at baseline as assessment reactivity has been found to be problematic in alcohol use disorder trials 47, 48. Considered together with the companion study, 17 the two PREMIUM trials represent a substantial achievement in global mental health for several reasons. First, the interventions are brief, delivered by lay people and provided to primary health-care attenders with few exclusion criteria, thus enhancing their generalisability to routine health care.…”

“…In this Article, we describe the results of a trial assessing the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of the CAP treatment when used in primary care. The study of HAP treatment is reported separately 17 . The two trials of HAP and CAP were done concurrently in the same primary health centres (PHCs) and over the same period of time, with the same counsellors delivering both treatments according to the trial allocations of participants.…”

Strengthening mental health care systems for Syrian refugees in Europe and the Middle East: integrating scalable psychological interventions in eight countries

“…An RCT in India (Patel et al, 2010) showed that a collaborative care intervention led by lay counsellors was cost-saving to the health system (Buttorff et al, 2012). A 6–8 session behavioral activation treatment delivered by lay counsellors in primary health care settings in India was also cost effective, reducing depression and improving functioning in people with moderately severe to severe depression (Patel et al, 2017; Weobong et al, 2017). A systematic review of task-shifting interventions for non-communicable diseases in LMICs showed that it is potentially effective for improving access for mental healthcare (Joshi et al, 2014).…”

Precision Medicine: From “Omics” to Economics towards Data-Driven Healthcare - Time for European Transformation

“…Solutions that bring the latest science from research to care will require new partnership models where stakeholders work on a more open agenda even in the early stage process of development [10] and greater sharing of information [11,12,13]. Approaches to integrate early stage research and pragmatic research aiming to improve effectiveness and public health values are being proposed [14,15].…”