The “here and now” of youth: the meanings of smoking for sexual and gender minority youth

Abstract

BackgroundThe mainstream tobacco field in the USA tends to situate youth as passive, particularly in terms of their susceptibility to industry manipulation and peer pressure. However, failing to acknowledge youths’ agency overlooks important meanings youth ascribe to their tobacco use and how those meanings are shaped by the circumstances and structures of their everyday lives.MethodsThis article is based on analysis of 58 in-depth qualitative interviews conducted with sexual and gender minority youth living in the San Francisco Bay area in California. Topics covered in interviews focused on meanings of tobacco in the lives of youth. Interviews lasted approximately 2.5 h and were transcribed verbatim and linked with ATLAS.ti, a qualitative data analysis software. Following qualitative coding, narrative segments were sorted into piles of similarity identified according to principles of pattern-level analysis to interpret to what extent meanings of smoking for young people may operate as forms of resistance, survival, and defense.ResultsAnalysis of our participants’ narratives highlights how smoking is connected to what Bucholtz calls the “‘here-and-now’ of young people’s experience, the social and cultural practices through which they shape their worlds” as active agents (Bucholtz, Annu Rev Anthropol31:525–52, 2003.). Specifically, narratives illustrate how smoking signifies “control” in a multitude of ways, including taking control over an oppressor, controlling the effects of exposure to traumatic or day-to-day stress, and exerting control over the physical body in terms of protecting oneself from violence or defending one’s mental health.ConclusionsThese findings call into question the universal appropriateness of foundational elements that underlie tobacco control and prevention efforts directed at youth in the USA, specifically the focus on abstinence and future orientation. Implications of these findings for research, prevention, and policy are discussed, emphasizing the risk of furthering health inequities should we fail to acknowledge the “here and now” of youth.

Places to Smoke: Exploring Smoking-Related Practices among Danish Adolescents

“…While some research addresses how smoking is experienced by different and combined social identities such as gender and race, (non)smoking as social identity is not addressed [ 49 , 50 ]. In light of the emphasis of non-smokers on the smokers’ status in this study, our findings underline the importance of this perspective.…”

Prevalence and correlates of concurrent use of cigarettes, electronic cigarettes, and waterpipes among Serbian youth

“…However, focusing only on the risks might make the smoking habit more attractive to youth. Failing to acknowledge this and focusing only on future risks may lead to losing the opportunity to reach adolescents with tailored interventions such as emphasizing the perceived benefits of quitting in the present 37 . Therefore, as recommended by other studies, the role of perceived social benefits should be considered in such interventions, as well as the need to increase adolescents’ awareness of the addictive nature of nicotine 38 .…”

Tobacco use, smoking identities and pathways into and out of smoking among young adults: a meta-ethnography

“…Three studies found that LGBTQ (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer/Questioning) young adults may start smoking due to factors which relate to their sexuality-related stressors, such as the stress of struggling with one’s sexual identity, sexual discrimination, prejudice or bullying [ 51 , 69 , 73 ]. Smoking was perceived as a tool for survival:…”