Creativity can be measured with a variety of methods including self-reports (e.g., creative interests), others reports (e.g., patent reports), and ability tests (e.g., divergent thinking). While typical self-reports are best understood as weak proxy variables of creativity, the application of biographical reports that assess previous creative activities seem more promising. Drawbacks of such measures—including skewed item distributions, a lack of measurement invariance across gender, and low convergent validity with established measures of creativity (such as divergent thinking tasks)—might be attributable to issues of item sampling. Therefore, we use a meta-heuristic algorithm (Ant Colony Optimization) to develop a short-scale of creative activities that a) maintains coverage of the original domains b) provides good model fit, c) has good reliability, d) demonstrates balanced item difficulty, e) is measurement invariant across gender, and f) possesses convergent validity with divergent thinking. For an 8-item short version of the original Inventory of Creative Activities and Achievements (ICAA) we identified an item set that satisfies all pre-specified criteria using data from N = 298 adults. We derive recommendations on the measurement of creative activities, and discuss implications for understanding creativity in general.