False memories are often demonstrated using the misinformation paradigm, in
which a person's recollection of a witnessed event is altered after exposure
to misinformation about the event. The neural basis of this phenomenon,
however, remains unknown. We used fMRI to investigate encoding processes
during the viewing of an event and misinformation to see whether neural
activity during either encoding phase could predict what would be remembered.
fMRI data were collected as participants studied eight vignettes (Original
Event phase). Shortly afterward, participants studied the same vignettes
during scanning, but with changes to several details, serving as the
misinformation (Misinformation phase). Two days later, their memories for the
Original Event were assessed. Activity that subsequently led to true and false
memories was examined during both encoding phases. Two interaction patterns
between encoding phase (Original Event and Misinformation) and type of memory
(true and false) were observed in MTL and PFC regions. In the left hippocampus
tail and perirhinal cortex, a predictive item-encoding pattern was observed.
During the Original Event phase, activity was greater for true than false
memories, whereas during the Misinformation phase, activity was greater for
false than true memories. In other regions, a pattern suggestive of source
encoding was observed, in which activity for false memories was greater during
the Original Event phase than the Misinformation phase. Together, these
results suggest that encoding processes play a critical role in determining
true and false memory outcome in misinformation paradigms.