The history of nursing in the home: revealing the significance of place in the expression of moral agency

Abstract

The history of nursing in the home: revealing the significance of place in the expression of moral agency The relationship between place and moral agency in home care nursing is explored in this paper. The notion of place is argued to have relevance to moral agency beyond moral context. This argument is theoretically located in feminist ethics and human geography and is supported through an examination of historical documents (1900-33) that describe the experiences and insights of American home care/private duty nurses or that are related to nursing ethics. Specifically, the role of place in inhibiting and enhancing care, justice, good relationships, and power in the practice of private duty nurses is explored. Several implications for current nursing ethics come out of this analysis. (i) The moral agency of nurses is highly nuanced. It is not only structured by nurses' relationships to patients and health professionals, i.e. moral context, it is also structured by the place of nursing care. (ii) Place has the potential to limit and enhance the power of nurses. (iii) Some aspects of nursing's conception of the good, such as what constitutes a good nurse-patient relationship, are historically and geographically relative.

Doing ‘technological time’ in a pediatric hemodialysis unit: An ethnography of children

“…A view of place where meanings and responses occur through situated embodied experiences and interactions, and in turn, places are made meaningful was employed (Manzo, 2003(Manzo, , 2005. The notion of embodied situatedness I drew on supported my view that the children perceive and respond to the timespace of the unit in multiple and meaning-making ways through their bodily senses, actions and words (Peter, 2002;Prout, 2000Prout, , 2005. Concepts of physical and social spaces facilitated my conceptualization of the unit as constituted by social relations and human-technological relations among providers and recipients of hemodialysis care as well as the physical setting (Andrews & Kitchin, 2005;Massey, 1994Massey, , 2004Massey, , 2005Ihde, 1990Ihde, , 1993).…”

“…Geographers as well as health care and nursing researchers have illustrated that places influence the health and wellbeing of people (Angus, Kontos, McKeever, Dyck, & Poland, 2005;McGibbon & Peter, 2008;McKeever et al, 2002;Moss & Dyck, 2002;Peter, 2002, Poland, Lehoux, Holmes, & Andrews, 2005Rapport, Doel, & Elwyn, 2007). Health geographers have drawn on and constructed notions of place in order to understand relations among locations, people, health status, and health care (Andrews, 2004;Andrews & Even, 2008;Andrews & Kitchin, 2005;Gesler & Kearns, 2002;Kearns & Moon, 2002;Lehoux, Genevieve, Poland, Andrews, & Holmes, 2007;Malpas, 2003;Poland et al, 2005).…”

“…Furthermore, my perspective on place encompassed senses of dis/attachments to and in places that I also endeavoured to learn about from the children (Casey, 1993(Casey, , 1997(Casey, , 2002Malone 2003;Manzo, 2005;Peter, 2002). The Delroy: Yeah.…”

Transfusing our lifeblood: Reframing research impact through inter-disciplinary collaboration between health geography and nurse education

“…It is well placed therefore to encourage other social science disciplines, such as demography, medical sociology (Allen, 2001), and anthropology to make similar contributions to a new critical pedagogy. (Health) geography's embrace of critical feminist scholarship (Liaschenko, 1997;Peter, 2002;Halford and Leonard, 2003;Dyck, 2003) that wrestles with the gendered meaning and control of (work) places provides a further point of alignment with nursing as part of platform for critical nursing pedagogy.…”

El cuidado a los ancianos: las valoraciones en torno al cuidado no familiar

“…Dos razones justifican este interés; uno, los hospitales y los asilos fueron opciones construidas para responder a las necesidades de los más desposeídos, es decir, los pobres sin familia y en torno a los cuales se construyeron las historias más negras de la institucionalización, 12 pero también los asilos han constituido espacios de opresión y disciplina, 13 a tal punto que el discurso de la desinstitucionalización durante el siglo XX se apoya en estas valoraciones como sus argumentos más fuertes. Es decir, los pobres han sido sus principales usuarios.…”