Human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) displays a broad cell tropism, and the infection of biologically relevant cells such as epithelial, endothelial, and hematopoietic cells supports viral transmission, systemic spread, and pathogenesis in the human host. HCMV strains differ in their ability to infect and replicate in these cell types, but the genetic basis of these differences has remained incompletely understood. In this study, we investigated HCMV strain VR1814, which is highly infectious for epithelial cells and macrophages and induces cell-cell fusion in both cell types. A VR1814-derived bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) clone, FIX-BAC, was generated many years ago but has fallen out of favor because of its modest infectivity. By sequence comparison and genetic engineering of FIX, we demonstrate that the high infectivity of VR1814 and its ability to induce syncytium formation in epithelial cells and macrophages depends on VR1814-specific variants of the envelope glycoproteins gB, UL128, and UL130. We also show that UL130-neutralizing antibodies inhibit syncytium formation, and a FIX-specific mutation in UL130 is responsible for its low infectivity by reducing the amount of the pentameric glycoprotein complex in viral particles. Moreover, we found that a VR1814-specific mutation in US28 further increases viral infectivity in macrophages, possibly by promoting lytic rather than latent infection of these cells. Our findings show that variants of gB and the pentameric complex are major determinants of infectivity and syncytium formation in epithelial cells and macrophages. Furthermore, the VR1814-adjusted FIX strains can serve as valuable tools to study HCMV infection of myeloid cells.