The Humble Charisma of a White-Dressed Man in a Desert Place: Pope Francis’ Communicative Style in the Covid-19 Pandemic

Abstract

The context of deep uncertainty, fear, and “social distancing” characterizing the COVID-19 pandemic has led to a need for cultural anchorages and charismatic leaders who may conjointly and effectively support human beings, strengthen their identity, and empower social commitment. In this perspective, the charismatic leadership of Pope Francis, which is widely shared not only within the religious world, may play a crucial role in facing emergency with existential reasons and psychological resources. The general aim of this work is to shed light on the communicative features of the charismatic leadership of Pope Francis during the pandemic emergency; in order to better understand his effectiveness, we analyzed both the core issues and his multimodal body signals in the global TV event of the Universal Prayer with the Urbi et Orbi Blessing. The multimodal and discursive analyses of the homily enabled us to define the “humble” charisma of the Pope, which is based upon on authentic and informal presence, manifested emotional signals (and, in particular commotion) showing features of equity and familiarity. From a discursive point of view, the common and overarching affiliation is constructed through a multiple focus on the “we” pronoun, which is constructed through socio-epistemic rhetoric. The results show how this integrated methodological perspectives, which is multimodal and discursive, may offer meaningful pathways detection of effective and persuasive signals.

Leader Narcissism and Employee Organizational Citizenship Behavior Directed Toward the Leader: Roles of Perceived Insider Status and Need for Self-Esteem

“…Organizations can evaluate and supervise the use of leaders’ power and reduce the possibility of narcissistic leaders abusing their power for personal gain. Humility is an interpersonal and epistemic stance ( D’Errico, 2020 ), which plays an important role in crisis management ( Scardigno et al, 2021 ) and has a tempering effect on narcissism ( Owens et al, 2015 ). Thus, organizations should provide leadership behavior training courses and promote humble leadership behavior.…”

“…Humility is an interpersonal and epistemic stance (D'Errico, 2020), which plays an important role in crisis management (Scardigno et al, 2021) and has a tempering effect on narcissism (Owens et al, 2015). Thus, organizations should provide leadership behavior training courses and promote humble leadership behavior.…”

“Everything Will Be All Right!” National and European Identification as Predictors of Positive Expectations for the Future During the COVID-19 Emergency

“…In social-psychological terms, he used Italians' shared identity as leverage to obtain greater compliance with the new restrictions as well as to preserve optimism and hope for the future. This communicative strategy, characterized by the emphasis on a sense of shared group membershipthat is, a sense of shared social identity, or "we-ness" -in citizens, has been successfully employed during the pandemic by political and religious leaders such as Pope Francis (Scardigno et al, 2021), or Jacinda Ardern, New Zealand's Prime Minister (Haslam et al, 2021).…”

“…Even though it is very likely that different political parties, different categories of workers, and other specific segments of the population (e.g., older people or the parents of schoolchildren) will have different interests, it is important that governments maintain and reinforce the idea that, despite divergences and the difficulty of making decisions that satisfy all parties, the country is facing a common fate and all involved parties must work toward a common goal. Citizens should feel that they can be proud of their nation and their government without forgetting that they are all "in the same boat" and should pursue a common goal (for similar reasoning, see Scardigno et al, 2021).…”

Twitter Mediated Sociopolitical Communication During the COVID-19 Pandemic Crisis in India

“…Crisis demands an integration of various skills on part of the leaders, as they are required to not simply respond to the crisis, but also manage the perception of the crisis at a larger level. Skills such as authenticity (Gigliotti, 2016), strategic thinking (Wang et al, 2021), effective communication (Wang et al, 2021;Kim and Liu, 2012), empathy (McGuire et al, 2020), humbleness (Scardigno et al, 2021) among others determine the perception of the effectiveness of the leader in managing the crisis.…”