The Impact of 3-Dimensional Reconstructions on Operation Planning in Liver Surgery

Abstract

Background: Operation planning in liver surgery depends on the precise understanding of the 3-dimensional (D) relation of the tumor to the intrahepatic vascular trees. To our knowledge, the impact of anatomical 3-D reconstructions on precision in operation planning has not yet been studied. Hypothesis: Three-dimensional reconstruction leads to an improvement of the ability to localize the tumor and an increased precision in operation planning in liver surgery. Design: We developed a new interactive computerbased quantitative 3-D operation planning system for liver surgery, which is being introduced to the clinical routine. To evaluate whether 3-D reconstruction leads to improved operation planning, we conducted a clinical trial. The data sets of 7 virtual patients were presented to a total of 81 surgeons in different levels of training. The tumors had to be assigned to a liver segment and subsequently drawn together with the operation proposal into a given liver model. The precision of the assignment to a liver segment according to Couinaud classification and the operation proposal were measured quantitatively for each surgeon and stratified concerning 2-D and different types of 3-D presentations. Results: The ability of correct tumor assignment to a liver segment was significantly correlated to the level of training (PϽ.05). Compared with 2-D computed tomography scans, 3-D reconstruction leads to a significant increase of precision in tumor localization by 37%. The target area of the resection proposal was improved by up to 31%. Conclusion: Three-dimensional reconstruction leads to a significant improvement of tumor localization ability and to an increased precision of operation planning in liver surgery.

A patient-specific surgical simulator using preoperative imaging data: an interactive simulator using a three-dimensional tactile mouse

“…Currently, some computer simulators are available for surgical training, but most have limited, pre-programmed scenarios [1,4,6]. In liver surgery, the use of an image processing workstation allows one to calculate resection volume and visualize completion images [16,17]. However, this existing system is not interactive, so the steps of the operation cannot be simulated.…”

Impact of model-based risk analysis for liver surgery planning

“…Previous studies in the field of liver surgery planning evaluated only the impact of 3D visualization [5] and virtual resection planning [6]. Thereby, the planning data was always compared with a presentation of 2D CT images.…”

Value of three-dimensional reconstructions in pancreaticcarcinoma using multidetector CT: Initial results

“…It was shown that the three-dimensional presentation did indeed lead to improved OP representation. Overall, three-dimensional presentation led to approaching a 31% higher precision in tumor localization and improvement in resection recommendations [20,21] . This study also illustrated the disadvantage of this method.…”