The Impact of Adding Online-to-Offline Service Platform Channels on Firms’ Offline and Total Sales and Profits

Abstract

Online-to-offline service platform (O2OSP) channels offer innovative means for customers to order local, daily services online (via apps) and have them delivered almost instantly offline. By comparing the business models underlying O2OSP, traditional online and offline, and platformbased e-commerce channels, this article aims to identify the short-and long-term impacts of adding an O2OSP channel on firms' offline and total sales and profits. The analysis focuses primarily on a recent set of daily data gathered from a Chinese fast-food restaurant chain with 35 physical stores that also participates in four food delivery O2OSP channels. The panel data regressions with fixed effects reveal that adding O2OSP channels hurts offline and total profits in the short run but improves offline and total sales and profits in the long run. Specifically, offline and total sales increase by 23.28% and 33.94%, respectively. Thus, the O2OSP channel can serve as a complement to, rather than a substitute for, the offline channel. These results challenge previous research on the sales effects of adding (pure) online or offline channels and highlight the attractiveness of O2OSP channels for improving sales and profits. However, negative interaction effects among different O2OSP channels also signal that adding more O2OSP channels does not necessarily lead to profitable growth.

Informational Challenges in Omnichannel Marketing: Remedies and Future Research

“…Unlike multichannel marketing, where marketing investments are optimized on a channel-by-channel basis, in an omnichannel setting, such optimization needs to be done jointly across all distribution and communication channels (Zhang, Pauwels, and Peng 2019). This becomes challenging when the purchase funnel has many stages and/or is traversed by customers in a nonsequential manner, as is often the case in the digital economy.…”

Digital Analytics: Modeling for Insights and New Methods

“…Legacy firms dominated by traditional brick-and-mortar business model, need to conform with the needs and habits of digital natives. Zhang, Pauwels, and Peng (2019) on the other hand investigate the impact of adding the online-to-offline service platform (O2OSP) channel on firms' offline and total sales and profits, and find that adding the O2OSP channel hurts offline and total sales in the short run, but in the long run the sales increase by about 23 percent and 33 percent, respectively.…”

Developing e-Booklet For Online Advertising: A Need Analysis On Enterpreneurship Education

“…This is ineffective and inefficient in time and effort because the market share is limited only when the seller passed the consumer, even though the potential consumer is very broad. Based on the article of Zhang (Zhang et al, 2019) -(introduction paragraph 2) many benefits will be gained from online marketing types, so due to schools already teach offline marketing, the writer will teach online marketing. The next step is to choose the right teaching media.…”

“…It is an online sales where purchases are made via mobile devices (online) but shipping offline. According to Zhang, Pauwels, & Peng (2019) online marketing has many advantages when compared to marketing Offline in general (banners, signposts, brochures), such as: (1) The coverage area on online is 5km, while offline is smaller that is 3km; (2) Service efficiency at online is higher while offline is lower; (3) Marketing ways on online faster while on offline is longer; (4) Marketing costs on online are cheaper while offline is more expensive.…”